After several months, what would be your Brawl rating?

[The Rawk Hawk]

Would you give the same rating to Brawl when the game launched compared to today?

I would still give 9 to this game...

What was your first rating and your actual rating?  

[l-Kathulu-l]

First rating was a 7. I didnt get all the way into it at first, it was a lot slower than melee and felt off.

Now I'd give it a 9. The action is frequent and many different characters so you can have many different battle experiences. I think they patched wifi up a little bit as well.  

[Waynebrizzle]

9 for bad online.  

[Delta Machine]

Waynebrizzle

9 for bad online.

 

[Super Cheesio]

I would have rated it 98%, but now it's more like 2% because it be killing mah Wii. crying  

[Owwin]

9/10. Wifi makes me so sad.  

[Meta_Fish]

I'd give it a niner, because it's got better balancing than Melee had, the physics have been changed to make the game more fun, and give it more air battles, it's easier to recover, it's not as twitch-based, and it just seems to be overall more fun than Melee because it's a bit slower and a bit lighter so it's not as serious and tourneyfag feeling. It's got a ton of characters, added Final Smashes, so many new items, stages, MUSIC, features, fdaklfjasdlkjsdf. I mean s**t, if you had a list of all of the anything it would be ridiculous; I don't see how they fit this much onto a disc of any size. It looks great, all the characters have been remodeled which shows for some like DK and Bowser. The single player is a million times better than the one in Melee, the cutscenes are completely fan service, and while it's not the best thing ever, it's still fun and it's even got co-op. You can take screenshots without being in ******** camera mode, you can record videos, you can make stages and send all of those to your friends over the internet. The online play is the only thing that isn't on par with the rest of the game, and I'm willing to forgive it because sometimes it works great.

NINE.  

[5ir Psycho 5exy]

Meh... 8. It's fun, but not worth the damage it allegedly does to my Wii. I would have been happier with Melee and a working console.  

[V1SUAL K31]

When I first got it: 10

Now: 9.5  

[System C O R R U P T]

10/10
The awesome Sound Test feature overpowers my dislike of the Wi-fi feature.

 

[Xilo The Odd]

Minase Iori

Waynebrizzle

9 for bad online.

 

[V1SUAL K31]

IT'S NANNERPUSS!!!!!!!!!  

[The Awkwardest Turtle]

At first: 10/10

Now: 8/10


Better than melee, but not the most awesome game in the world.  

[The Resolve]

9 because of the crappy online AND horrible level design (You heard me, New Pork City). And tripping.