Welcome to Gaia! ::

Reply 01
Mana Walker-CAUTION-Possible Spoilers for some...

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Hal B Noire

Dapper Explorer

PostPosted: Mon May 19, 2008 3:30 pm


User Image
Long long time ago, there was a cradle.
And in the cradle, there is another cradle.
One cradle has become a twin now.



Well we know by now that it's pretty obvious that he is the mysterious 14th Noah member (a.k.a the Musician) who became a traitor. I'm just really curious as to whether he is a bad guy or not, considering how he taught Allen the song. Also the fact that the Noah are not as bad as the series makes them out to be (in reference to the previous chapter) gets me wondering who are the bad guys in this.

I really hope that Mana thought of Allen as a precious son, but I can't help but get the feeling that he also had the ulterior motive of using him to get revenge on the Earl and the Noah family by teaching him that song. In addition to that is the probability that Allen is possessor of the Heart of the Innocence, or at least possessor of half.

And then there is that curse of Allen's. Was it really all an accident/coincidence? Or is there something in all that as well. Again the Earl had mentioned something about that during the Noah Family get together as if to say that it was a set up that he could have avoided. Is there anyone else who feels these kind of possible theories?



And one of the cradles gets lost in the fog by itself.
A star is shining brightly at the sacred place.
And dissapeared.
User Image


User Image
 
PostPosted: Tue May 20, 2008 11:42 am


I think Mana is not the 14th, maybe he has a certain relation to him, but can Noah really become Akuma?

But, you might be right if Noah's -can- turn into Akumas like humans do.

Actually, I suspect Cross more than I suspect Mana of being the 14th. I mean, come on.

He found Allen as soon as Mana dies and took in an apprentice, something he'd never done before.

Plus, he knows how to make docile Akuma. Remember Chomesuke?

Quwrof

Tipsy Fairy


Hal B Noire

Dapper Explorer

PostPosted: Fri May 23, 2008 9:34 pm


Ruriku
I think Mana is not the 14th, maybe he has a certain relation to him, but can Noah really become Akuma?

But, you might be right if Noah's -can- turn into Akumas like humans do.

Actually, I suspect Cross more than I suspect Mana of being the 14th. I mean, come on.

He found Allen as soon as Mana dies and took in an apprentice, something he'd never done before.

Plus, he knows how to make docile Akuma. Remember Chomesuke?

User Image
Long long time ago, there was a cradle.
And in the cradle, there is another cradle.
One cradle has become a twin now.


No, Cross can't be the 14th. First of all the Earl has never referred to Cross as the 14th before. Although he considers him a danger, he never said anything about him being part of the Noah family and neither have the other members.

Plus if you've read the battle in the Noah Ark, you'll notice during the chat between The Earl and Cross that the 14th is an entirely different person.

Proof the 14th is not Cross

And if you've been keeping track after reading D. Gray-man, you'll notice that much of the evidence points to Mana as the 14th.



And one of the cradles gets lost in the fog by itself.
A star is shining brightly at the sacred place.
And dissapeared.
User Image


User Image
PostPosted: Thu Jun 19, 2008 8:33 pm


I know...

But what if the mangaka just wants us to think the 14th is Mana? :0

Waay back when The Earl didn't kill Allen after making Mana an Akuma, wouldn't The Earl -know- Mana was the 14th?

I would so kill Allen if he was my enemy's foster child who somehow got the 14th's powers passed down...

So maybe Hoshino-sensei just wants to make us -think- it's Mana but it's someone else... I used Cross as an example since he seems to know a lot, but it could happen that it's not Mana. It wouldn't be the 1st time a mangaka hints for something only to reveal it ain't true. :0

For now I'll be waiting for the revelation of the mysterious 14th. Dx

(Until that happens... CHIBI KANDA AND LAVI AND LONG HAIRED, KOMURIN WOOING, ALLEN!~ SQUEEEEE! heart )

Quwrof

Tipsy Fairy


fullmetal_ranma

Dangerous Hunter

6,250 Points
  • Entrepreneur 150
  • Wall Street 200
  • Junior Trader 100
PostPosted: Sat Jul 12, 2008 6:26 pm


Allen is the 14th's "Memories", it's true because I read the chapter 166. And Cross actually knew this, and that the 14th had a brother, who is Mana Walker. And thet he is "the host necessary his revival."
PostPosted: Sat Aug 23, 2008 2:36 pm


There are a lot of twists and turns. Who knows?...

Keeping me thinking like this is good, I should say. xD
Quite exciting.

vokee


PuppetsMask

PostPosted: Tue Jul 07, 2009 11:13 pm


If Mana was 14th's brother,
then wouldn't Mana be #13 or #15?
Or 14th was a child and was adopted into a human family when he was young after he escaped the Noah family,
something like that I suppose.
The next chapter will be about Kanda and the tattoo since it ended like that with Kanda and his teacher or what-ever-his-face-is.
Reply
01

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum