Are Catholics Christian?

Are Catholics Christian?

Yes.	77.3%	[ 334 ]
No.	22.7%	[ 98 ]
Total Votes:			[ 432 ]

This poll closed on December 29, 2006.
No longer accepting new votes.

[ufc campbell]

one problem with ur.... theory...the catholics were the first christians....so they must be doing some thing right or god would have never let them become a major power

[[.BaNaNa.CoIn.]]

that's so not true!
Catholics worship Jesus and Gods...not only Mary..... stare

[rika may]

i hope u know that catholics were the first christians confused

[Rookherst[KOS]]

rika may

i hope u know that catholics were the first christians confused

Proof Please?
Gnostics and Eastern Orthodox are just as old.

[armybabe09]

Rookherst[KOS]

rika may

i hope u know that catholics were the first christians confused

Proof Please?
Gnostics and Eastern Orthodox are just as old.

... well they might be "just as old" in your opinion, but the catholic church was the first.
it was started by Peter. soooo... it was the first one, guys.

[Rookherst[KOS]]

armybabe09

... well they might be "just as old" in your opinion,

by opinon you mean fact?

Quote:

but the catholic church was the first.

Prove or Concede

Quote:

it was started by Peter.

Prove or concede.

Quote:

soooo... it was the first one, guys.

Prove this.

[Cadaveric Spasm]

A Christian is anyone who believes that Jesus Christ was the son of God and our saviour.

Therefore, Catholics = Christians.

They're just a different sect.

Get your facts straight.

[armybabe09]

Rookherst[KOS]

armybabe09

... well they might be "just as old" in your opinion,

by opinon you mean fact?

Quote:

but the catholic church was the first.

Prove or Concede

Quote:

it was started by Peter.

Prove or concede.

Quote:

soooo... it was the first one, guys.

Prove this.

no i mean opinion as opinion. or else i would have said fact.

click here
there.

[Rookherst[KOS]]

armybabe09

no i mean opinion as opinion. or else i would have said fact.

Exept, that...you know. It's not an Opinion it's fact.

Quote:

click here
there.

Appeal To Authority




If Catholics were the first Christians, that fundamentally denies Christ's Ministry. By this thinking, PETER and peter alone was the only Diciple.

The first Christians were the Diciples of Christ. That is why you fail.

[sickday]

Wow, aren't you kind of late to be making these kind of statements? I mean, we went over all of this nearly five hundred years ago. (By the way, Catholics don't worship Mary, they pray with Mary as an intercessor to God.)

Besides....

PROTESTANTS CONTROL THE WORLD!!

[armybabe09]

Rookherst[KOS]

armybabe09

no i mean opinion as opinion. or else i would have said fact.

Exept, that...you know. It's not an Opinion it's fact.

Quote:

click here
there.

Appeal To Authority




If Catholics were the first Christians, that fundamentally denies Christ's Ministry. By this thinking, PETER and peter alone was the only Diciple.

The first Christians were the Diciples of Christ. That is why you fail.

when i said opinion, i meant opinion. the end.

i know the first christians were the disciples... your point? peter wasnt the only one. he was the founder of the church. then that made catholics/christians. so... yeah.

ok, i aint catholic. but i go to a catholic school. im protestant. hoorah.

[.Panic![Malfunction].]

Surf Kitty 69

Do you consider Catholics to be Christian?

Catholics are Christian.

Quote:

Catholics aren't Christian.

Christianity is a monotheistic religion centered on Jesus of Nazareth and his life, death, resurrection, and teachings.

Quote:

They claim to be, but they worship the virgin Mary, and not Jesus or God.

Wrong, they pray to all three of them.

Quote:

Also, they dance pagan dances around that huge hat the pope has, when the Bible says that nobody should keep idols.

Depending on the version. Catholics version of the bible doesn't say that.

Quote:

Please save your souls before it's too late.

Also, no thank you.

[Rookherst[KOS]]

armybabe09

when i said opinion, i meant opinion. the end.

Not the end. You said it was my opinion that some traditions are as old if not older then Catholicism. That wasn't my opinion. It was objective Fact.

Quote:

i know the first Christians were the disciples... your point?

The Disciples weren't Catholic.

Quote:

peter wasn't the only one.

According to your "Catholics were the first Christians" statement, he was.

Quote:

he was the founder of the church. then that made catholics/christians. so... yeah.

he was the founder of a Organized Christian....Not all the Diciples were Catholcis, and they started their own tradtions. Therfore: There are Tradtions just as old as Catholicism

Quote:

ok, i aint catholic. but i go to a catholic school. im protestant. hoorah.

Glad to see they give you unbaised Information in those schools rolleyes

[caemin]

ummm YES!!!! Catholics are Christian. the majority of other branches of Christainity, with the exception of Greek and Russian Orthodox came off of the Roman Catholic Church. In fact during the Middle Ages, there was only one Church and it was the Roman Catholic Church.

as to your comment about the virgin Mary... Catholics worship her as almost like a saint but better. She's not just the main focus of worship. Jesus and God are too, just like in all branches of christainity.

[sickday]

Silver Dragon Hate

Christianity is a monotheistic religion centered on Jesus of Nazareth and his life, death, resurrection, and teachings.

Surf Kitty 69

They claim to be, but they worship the virgin Mary, and not Jesus or God.

Wrong, they pray to all three of them.

Actually, by that logic, Christians in general aren't monotheistic. There's only one God.