Casey12347
I don't really agree with this. I understand where you're coming from, but I don't believe that to be grounds to chuck the newbie packs entirely.
So, mostly, what you're saying is that they don't have to work to get their stuff, because they're given all these things at the beginning, yes? Or at least, their incentive for going out and buying things is taken away. I don't think that's really true. It may be true for those people who don't really care what their avatar looks like, those people who are just here for the forums, or here because their friends dragged them onto the site, but certainly not for everyone. Weather or not I got all those items at the beginning, I would still go questing for cooler things. The only differece would be that I have a variety of clothing to start with and play around with instead of the ever-so-affordable peasant garb.
I have no doubt that new users will continue to go out and quest for more. It just seems to be.. one of those things, you know? That satisfaction that you have when you're new and you can finally.. clothe yourself! XD It's just one of those things. We all went through it.
Casey12347
You say that your avatar is one of your favorite parts of Gaia. Well, without clothes, the newbies don't get to play with it! This gives them the chance to mix-and-match, and have fun with one of the major parts of Gaia right from the start. There's not that much flexibility when all you can afford is peasant clothing.
One of the reasons that my avatar is my favorite part of Gaia is because of how hard I've worked to accumulate what I have. For example, I rarely wear my duckie hat anymore. But I would never get rid of it..! I wear my OMG because of the fuss I went through to get it.. I remember all of the times I envied other users because they had fairy wings and I couldn't afford them.
I'm not saying that having a starter set makes newbs any richer. But.. like.. it just gives them this safety net that we never had. If two users were to start right now, one with the older starter, and one with the new starter set, could you disagree that the one with the new set would undoubtedly get farther quicker?
Casey12347
The clothing, with three different colors per item, and a butt-load of different items, allows even newbies to have original avatars, right from the start. Everyone wants to be original, right?
mrgreen
The new clothing doesn't take away that feeling of acomplishment when you've completed a quest, or bought your first nifty-looking article of clothing. There's no reason that it would. (Aaaaand... My train of thought died.
xd )
I don't think the newb packs are going to change things as drastically as you're making it out to be.
(And out of randomness, you asked:
"Besides, how do you tell a newbie from an older user?"
Honestly, if I'm curious, I check their profile. O_o It kinda says when the account was created.)
Doesn't always work, though. So many mules, so many people transferring items.
xp
Anyway, I totally respect your opinion.
3nodding You have a lot of valid points. I'm just a greedy Gaian.
xd