Phoebe's Soul Mate

[Knight of Shadows]

In the episode All Halliwell's Eve, the sisters traveled back in time to save a baby. At one point a man stops Phoebe and offeres to show her the first letter of the name of her true love. The letter turned out to be "C" so she assumed it was Cole...but was it? Who do you think it was?  

[charmedfreak880]

hmm never really thought of that....i actually just saw that episode this morning. I do think it was Cole because when things happen the future get changed and stuff..  

[babyshady]

I have no idea.. Cole and CHris are the only ones with C, right?.. I don't know  

[Knight of Shadows]

babyshady

I have no idea.. Cole and CHris are the only ones with C, right?.. I don't know

the reason I asked is that she had an old boyfriend named Clay. When he came back to her in one episode she thought he could be the real thing, and he was willing to risk his life at the end of the episode to save phoebe. Its the only relationship that I could think of that hasnt ended badly. Maby they will bring him back this season to get pheobe knocked up like she saw in the future... lol  

[babyshady]

Knight of Shadows

babyshady

I have no idea.. Cole and CHris are the only ones with C, right?.. I don't know

the reason I asked is that she had an old boyfriend named Clay. When he came back to her in one episode she thought he could be the real thing, and he was willing to risk his life at the end of the episode to save phoebe. Its the only relationship that I could think of that hasnt ended badly. Maby they will bring him back this season to get pheobe knocked up like she saw in the future... lol

Oh yeah, he's another C... I don't know, let's hope they tell us early in the next season!  

[13lackMagic]

Knight of Shadows

babyshady

I have no idea.. Cole and CHris are the only ones with C, right?.. I don't know

the reason I asked is that she had an old boyfriend named Clay. When he came back to her in one episode she thought he could be the real thing, and he was willing to risk his life at the end of the episode to save phoebe. Its the only relationship that I could think of that hasnt ended badly. Maby they will bring him back this season to get pheobe knocked up like she saw in the future... lol

that would rock! I liked Clay, but have we seen him since the 1st season?  

[Princess Fief]

I think Cole was her true love, her soulmate. Even though he did end up dying, he was still her true love.  

[Wicca1]

I think your right about cole being her soul mate. But eh, another C...who knows.

And was clay in season 1? I thought it was much later. I could be wrong though. Its been a while since Ive seen those earlier episodes....come to think of it. that may be right. Maby it was season 1. I dunno.  

[Soma4sama]

who ever her sole mate is I hope it is a new guy with a job and is a withch so he can defend himself an help the sisters  

[13lackMagic]

Soma4sama

who ever her sole mate is I hope it is a new guy with a job and is a withch so he can defend himself an help the sisters

Agreed, maybe not a witch, but magical! ^_^  

[Mizu Sayuri]

Lol, Cole was hott too! And I also think that Cole was and might still be her soulmate. They were so cute together!  

[qtkatgirl263]

Okay, well. What do you think an orange peel would go back to? Orange peels are resilient, no atter how much you mangle with them! How could someone be so stupid to believe that! You know, I bet if that guy did that to everyone, they would be going up to someone whose name startes with a "C." evil  

[13lackMagic]

qtkatgirl263

Okay, well. What do you think an orange peel would go back to? Orange peels are resilient, no atter how much you mangle with them! How could someone be so stupid to believe that! You know, I bet if that guy did that to everyone, they would be going up to someone whose name startes with a "C." evil

ok, I'm not sure if I got that or not.. XxSpoilerxX: but what about Coop? (new guy.. cupid) So I dunno, I don't think they'll bring Cole back either.  

[Saiyajin-Neko]

qtkatgirl263

Okay, well. What do you think an orange peel would go back to? Orange peels are resilient, no atter how much you mangle with them! How could someone be so stupid to believe that! You know, I bet if that guy did that to everyone, they would be going up to someone whose name startes with a "C." evil

Ok
1: IT WAS AN APPLE!!!
2: Apples are the fruit of knowledge
3: Non believers wouldn't get it even if it was true. gonk  

[Knight of Shadows]

you sure it was an apple. Im pretty sure it was an orange.