Dumbles or Voldie-Where is Snape? HBP spoiler

[batmannings]

Amba Smith

Veriverta

CarrieKat

but what is dumbledore had hoxcrues{sp?} to? then He would be dead and alive sweatdrop

Exactly! And he may do the Phoenix thing and will somehow be reborn. Do we forget what he was a member of? wink

Yeah. I also think that maybe Dumbledore has like died before?..... It just seems that he knows too much about death when he hasn't died himself.
I don't think that Dumbledore has horcruxes. Besides isn't he the one that goes on about Voldie not knowing the like greatness of a whole soul.

Well...ya. And he does know alot about death, it may be from experiance. Oooo...spooky... eek  

[Salomelove]

Zaurak

I don't think Snape is evil... Sonehow it doesn't make sense for him to be.(And I don't even like Snape that much!) Remember, we never found out why Dumbledore trusted Snape so fully. Plus, I absolutely cannot eblieve Dumbledore would beg not to be killed. Beg to be killed in order to further the eventual downfall of Lord Voldemort? Yes. Dumbledore would sacrifivce ghis life if he thought it would help. There's too many pieces of the puzzle that don't fit unless you view it in context of Snape still working for Dumbledore.

Though, he's gonnahave a hell of a time explaining all this. razz

I agree, I don't think Snape is evil either. We have only begun to hear his story and I think there will be more to it in the last book.