Kreacher or Dobby?

[Psycho_Ryko]

Dobby has his faults, but I'd take him over Kreacher  

[Empress_Kat]

I adore Kreacher, he's awesome. Dobby has always annoyed me a bit too much.  

[Violet Amastacia]

I love Dobby...I never did care for Kreacher much at all.  

[Niozik]

Violet Amastacia

I love Dobby...I never did care for Kreacher much at all.

Yea, who cares if you have to pay him, probably not even that much.  

[Lovestruck Soul]

I prefer Dobby...he is so...obediant...but yet rebellious  

[[~Uzumaki_Naruto~]]

I like Dobby better then Kreacher. Kreacher is somewhat funny, but he also made Harry think Voldemort had Sirius. domokun So I can't like him better then Dobby, no matter how funny his Christmas Presents are. <3  

[BahamutIIX]

Too close. I would have to flip a coin.  

[Niozik]

BahamutIIX

Too close. I would have to flip a coin.

Well I probably wouldn't be full blood, and I couldn't take Kreacher's snide comments all the time. I'd kill myself.  

[KimCL]

I would want Dobby so I could make him say bad things about the Malfoys then watch him kill himself.  

[Empress_Kat]

KimCL

I would want Dobby so I could make him say bad things about the Malfoys then watch him kill himself.

That's mean, but so so funny! I will be eternally amused by that mental picture...  

[yertle]

Dobby is creepy.... gonk

Go kreacher!! sweatdrop  

[David FTW]

KimCL

I would want Dobby so I could make him say bad things about the Malfoys then watch him kill himself.

;;>.> That's a bit creepy, don't ya' think?

 

[David FTW]

yertle

Dobby is creepy.... gonk

Go kreacher!! sweatdrop

.-. So, Kreacher talks to himself thinking that you won't be able to hear him and Dobby just hits himself over the head alot over a few words and wants to be paid for working.
But still, you would pick Kreacher? gonk Oh, dear god. Both are creepy.

 

[Lepidus Light]

To tell the truth, I don't really like either of them. Dobby is a little too enthusiastic and he tends to try to be a tad bit...too helpful, if you look back to Chamber of Secrets.

Kreacher annoys me since he's the overzealous, pure-blood lover with no good side. He seems to constantly be grumpy, which doesn't strike me as very becoming...

But if I had to chose one, Dobby would be the better of the two in my eyes. ^^  

[Imbri]

Dobby rawks. Totally.

I especially loved the socks he made for Harry for Christmas.