Welcome to Gaia! ::


Quote:
How the Demographic Shift Could Hurt Democrats, Too

Ryan D. Enos, Washington Post, March 8, 2013

Since the November election, in which President Obama won huge majorities among minority voters, it’s been taken as gospel that the Republican Party must, for its own survival, seek to appeal to those groups by moving to the left on topics such as immigration reform. But as the nation becomes more diverse, the demographic shift can cut the other way, too: Some Democratic voters are likely to move to the right.

It’s assumed that, as the United States becomes increasingly non-white, white Democrats will continue to support the party. But a substantial amount of social-science evidence suggests a different conclusion: As the United States becomes more racially and ethnically diverse, liberal whites might start leaning Republican.

Consider a straightforward experiment I conducted last year: Over two weeks, I sent pairs of Latino men in their 20s to ride commuter trains in the greater Boston area, often cited as one of the nation’s most liberal regions.

These people were not asked to do anything out of the ordinary, just to wait for the train and ride it. The pairs I sent were native Spanish speakers, so when they spoke to each other, it was probably in Spanish. To gauge other riders’ attitudes about Latinos, I surveyed them before the experiment and two weeks into the tests. In each case, the trains and times were randomly selected and were later compared with a control group of riders on different trains. These trains originated in communities with very few Latino residents, and the men I sent to ride the trains were often the only Latinos at those stations on a day-to-day basis. In this sense, the experiment was testing how people react when a very small group of Latinos moves to a new community.

The results were clear. After coming into contact, for just minutes each day, with two more Latinos than they would otherwise see or interact with, the riders, who were mostly white and liberal, were sharply more opposed to allowing more immigrants into the country and favored returning the children of illegal immigrants to their parents’ home country. It was a stark shift from their pre-experiment interviews, during which they expressed more neutral attitudes.

Political scientists, economists, sociologists and psychologists have long noted that, under most circumstances, when people from different ethnic, racial and religious groups come into new contact, conflict ensues.

And those conflicts often change the way people vote.

In the 1930s, political scientist V.O. Key found evidence that, in Southern counties with large numbers of African Americans, white voters were politically mobilized: They voted more than whites in neighboring counties and supported candidates espousing discriminatory views in greater numbers.

In a more recent example, the city of Chicago began a massive effort in 2000 to overhaul its public housing. Large and notorious housing projects, such as Cabrini-Green, were demolished, and their residents were relocated. More than 99 percent of the relocated residents were African American. The outcome of the effort was the reverse of my experiment in Boston—rather than coming into contact, groups were separated.

Did that separation result in more liberal political views? Voting patterns among white residents living near these projects before and after their demolition showed that it did. After their African American neighbors left, fewer white residents turned out to vote, and voters became less likely to choose Republican candidates, whom they had previously supported at higher levels than had residents in other parts of the city.

To explore whether there was a similar effect among minority voters, in 2008 I conducted an experiment in which I sent a letter to African American voters just before an election in Los Angeles. The content of the letter was simple: It reminded people to vote and included a map noting how often people on their block voted compared with a nearby block. In some randomly selected cases, the comparison block consisted of African American residents; in others, it was largely Latino. When the letter pointed to a majority-Latino block, African Americans were significantly more likely to vote, suggesting that they were concerned about political competition with Latinos — even though both groups vote overwhelmingly for Democrats.

In that same year, I examined the voting of Latinos in Los Angeles and found that those who lived near predominantly African American neighborhoods were far less likely to vote for Obama than Latinos who lived farther away — suggesting that contact with their African American neighbors may have prompted them to vote against an African American candidate.

As different groups come into contact, people often have adverse reactions, and this can cause them to vote for a party that represents opposition to other groups.

Friendly Wench

Huh, how sad. I could be surrounded by 100 Latinos and all I would think is "Damn. I think I'm in the wrong place....o _ o" because where am I going honestly going to be surrounded by 100 Latinos on a regular basis?
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
Huh, how sad. I could be surrounded by 100 Latinos and all I would think is "Damn. I think I'm in the wrong place....o _ o" because where am I going honestly going to be surrounded by 100 Latinos on a regular basis?


my neighborhood.

Original Rogue

11,100 Points
  • Battle: Rogue 100
  • Demonic Associate 100
  • The Wolf Within 100
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
Huh, how sad. I could be surrounded by 100 Latinos and all I would think is "Damn. I think I'm in the wrong place....o _ o" because where am I going honestly going to be surrounded by 100 Latinos on a regular basis?
My church. Seriously.

Friendly Wench

Honey of the South
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
Huh, how sad. I could be surrounded by 100 Latinos and all I would think is "Damn. I think I'm in the wrong place....o _ o" because where am I going honestly going to be surrounded by 100 Latinos on a regular basis?
My church. Seriously.

Haha well I don't ever plan on going to your church or any church so I'm good there! I actually don't see very many Latinos in my area and always wonder where the "Damn beaners are everywhere!" that the racist hicks are always going off about actually are. xd
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
Honey of the South
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
Huh, how sad. I could be surrounded by 100 Latinos and all I would think is "Damn. I think I'm in the wrong place....o _ o" because where am I going honestly going to be surrounded by 100 Latinos on a regular basis?
My church. Seriously.

Haha well I don't ever plan on going to your church or any church so I'm good there! I actually don't see very many Latinos in my area and always wonder where the "Damn beaners are everywhere!" that the racist hicks are always going off about actually are. xd

In their heads usually. Placed there by the boogeyman.

Friendly Wench

Shama_okami

That's what I thought. I actually went of on one such person when I was in highschool, and he was going off about how he couldn't get a job because beaners. I turned around and asked him "Is it maybe because you're in highschool? Because you hold a D average? Because you won't work in fastfood?" To which he replied "Well this is none of YER business! I wasn't TALKING to you!" Even though he was shouting. How stupid can people even be? rolleyes
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
How stupid can people even be? rolleyes

I used to wonder this. Then I worked in fast food. It's like asking how big space is. Every time you think you found the limit you realize it just keeps going.

Friendly Wench

Shama_okami
O_o-Dimensia_Juice-x_X
How stupid can people even be? rolleyes

I used to wonder this. Then I worked in fast food. It's like asking how big space is. Every time you think you found the limit you realize it just keeps going.

Ah fast food, I couldn't think of a better comparison. The idiots I dealt with never ceased to amaze me.

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum