Welcome to Gaia! :: View User's Journal | Gaia Journals

 
 

View User's Journal

Rantings and Grumblings
In which: I rant about whatever suits my fancy.
On the trial of Joan of Arc
Many people do not hear the voice of any gods at all.

I suspect that this is because many people do not listen. To be fair, I've never heard the Christian god nor any saint--I don't wish to. I don't imagine they would like me very much, because they're pretty clear about that one god thing.

But I suspect most people don't quite realise that it can actually happen. It's a bit of a physical shock, really, when it does.

I believe Joan heard her saints. Occam's Razor: is it more likely that a teenage peasant went batshit nuts and off to war, or more likely she heard and made vows to saints? If she was truly pious, as she was by all accounts, then I suspect that the latter is more likely. Why did she wear men's clothing? Well... again, think about it. She made a vow of chastity. Seems like a reasonable way to keep it, yes? Or maybe god told her to.

Sometimes the gods ask for weird but ultimately harmless things. The Morrigan asked you to pour libations for her daily -- or else? uh okay please don't get mad have at it. Mercury set you to building cairns at crossroads? Have fun, don't get sunburned hunting for all those stones. Saint Catherine said to cut your hair and stop wearing dresses? Seems legit. And hey, short hair is easy to maintain.

In other words, I judge that Joan was sane and her accusers were more likely to be the heretics acting against their god. Because their god is well known to be rather... unamused... by such behaviours, I'm quite sorry for them.





 
 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum