Welcome to Gaia! ::

The Full Metal Alchemist Official guild

Back to Guilds

 

 

Reply The Full Metal Alchemist Official guild
FMA Manga Dead?

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

Kyoukage

PostPosted: Sat Sep 02, 2006 7:52 pm


I've been waiting for the new FMA manga for like four months and nothing has come. (I read them off of sites like readmanga and such) Then someone pointed out that when the anime ends before the manga, the manga dies out. They stop making them. Anybody know anything I don't?
PostPosted: Sun Sep 03, 2006 11:51 am


Well the person who said that is lying. I mean...take the anime fruits basket, its all done but a manga series is still coming out. So don't worry, the new one will come out soon.

[-cuteandbeloved-]
Crew


GreedsLittleEdo

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2006 12:44 am


yea i don't know where your getting this from because i've been downloading chapter's every month when they come out..
PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2006 1:23 am


I should probably start reading the manga... I hear its alot better than the anime.

Could anyone tell me at which manga issue the storyline splits from the anime's

LtCol.Hughes


d_ninty

PostPosted: Mon Sep 04, 2006 1:01 pm


i just read on readmanga, I have no hope of buying the mangas, as i live in the uk
PostPosted: Tue Sep 05, 2006 7:34 pm


LtCol.Hughes
I should probably start reading the manga... I hear its alot better than the anime.

Could anyone tell me at which manga issue the storyline splits from the anime's


the manga never really "splits away" but i guess you could say that there were more noticible changes between the two in vol. 8 i think. the endings differ, and there are different characters in the manga that are never even shown in the anime, like ling. also, winry is in the manga a lot more than she is in the anime. there are a couple smaller changes too like for ecample... *spoiler* when they go to rush valley, ed, al, winry, and paninya (sp?) help to deliver a baby, when in the anime ed and al help deliver hughes daughter.*

if you want to know EVERYTHING different in the maga, here is a summery of THE HNTIRE MANGA SERIES: *MAJOR SPOILER WARNING*

*Ed goes home to Resembool to find Hohenheim, his father, standing at his mother's grave. After a brief argument, Hohenheim and Ed walk to Pinako's with Ed hostile and belligerent towards his father. While Ed pretends to be asleep, he overhears his father questioning Pinako on whether the body Ed and Al created by transmutation was Trisha revived. This question spurs Ed's curiosity, and after Hohenheim leaves the next day, Ed asks Pinako to go with him to the graveyard to dig up the body he and Al created so many years ago. He starts throwing up and has to take several breaks while digging, but eventually pulls up a lock of hair; black hair instead of brown. Pinako also points out that the bones aren't the same length as Trisha's were. So Ed learns that they didn't even bring back their mother, but brought back something entirely different.

Ed goes to central to find Al is missing his lower "jaw" and his right arm of his suit of armor. After Ed repairs Al, he finds out Al had a run in with Barry the Chopper and the homunculi, but also finds out that Al learned that the soul, when not placed in its original body, can reject the substitute body, just as the human body can reject organ transplants. This rejection may occur within seconds of the soul being placed on a new body, or may not occur for hundreds of years, but rejection is inevitable.

He tells Al and Winry, after asking about an incident when they were five, that he is confirming the memories Ed has that Al doesn't have. Al and Winry allude to a moment when Ed was unconscious and fighting a fever after surgery when Winry walked in on Al, who was "resting," and they talk. Only, when Al and Winry allude to the conversation, it sounds almost like they played multiple pranks on Ed, causing Ed to become irritated and ask them to stop talking.

When they get back to the conversation at hand, Ed theorizes that Al's body is with Truth inside the gate and that it's still alive and possibly connected through Ed and Al's blood to Ed. (That he is sleeping, eating, etc. for the both of them.) Al's brain is still alive inside a body that's still alive and it is collecting the memories since Ed transferred Al's soul to the suit of armor. At this point, Al also remembers when he opened the Gate of Truth, he found himself in there, rather than his mother, as he expected. He also realized that his soul was placed on the body that he and Ed had transmuted, and even saw Ed from the body's eyes. However, rejection took place almost immediately after his soul was placed onto the body. As a sidenote, because Al's body is biologically connected to Ed, Ed has enthusiastically hypothosized that he may grow taller once Al's body is recovered since he won't have to eat (or grow) for both bodies.

Ed and Al eventually figure the only way they're going to catch a Homunculus (and the philosopher's stone within them) is to let Scar attack them, and tries to attract Scar's attention. Ed does a series of do-gooding around town (while showing off as much and as loudly as possible to get Scar to notice him) and eventually succeeds. A fight between Scar, Ed and Al ensues, with Mustang and Hawkeye diverting attention from them by redirecting the military vehicles to different places away from where the real fight is happening. Winry goes looking for them and ends up overhearing Ed accusing Scar of killing Winry's parents. She picks up the gun an officer dropped and points it at Scar, only to have Ed jump in front of her and tell her to drop the gun while Scar descends on him from the front. When Scar sees this, he hesitates, remembering his own brother protecting him from Kimblee's attack during the Eastern War. Seeing his hesitation, Al attacks Scar, driving him away from the two.

Then, Ling ties up Gluttony and Winry is going to Rush Valley once more. Gluttony escapes his bonds and tries to suck up Roy and everyone else into his "gate" for a stomach. He ends up sucking up Envy, Ling and Ed, instead, and Al's left hand. Ling and Ed find Envy eventually and Envy actually tries to be nice to Ed, however, it all backfires and Envy turns into his true form.

The tortured souls in Envy's natural form cause Ed to have a semi-nervous breakdown (he cannot bear to hurt them and flashes back to Nina for an instant). Envy then swallows him. However, after seeing the philosopher's stone that is Envy's center, he kicks out one of Envy's teeth and tells Envy and Ling that he knows a way that they can escape from Gluttony's stomach.

In the recent chapters, Ed realized that while human revival is impossible, since equivalent exchange requires the existence of the soul in question, it is possible to open the Gate of Truth by transmuting existing humans using themselves as the starting materials. This does not violate the rule of equivalent exchange, but still is a form of human transmutation, and so is a way of opening the Gate of Truth. Using the souls inside Envy as the "Toll," Ed successfully transmuted himself, Envy, and Ling, and opened the Gate once more. This time, he sees a second Gate, as well as an emaciated Alphonse sitting in front of the second gate. Ed yells for Al's body to come with him. However, Al's body told Ed that he could not go with Ed back to the real world because Ed had a different soul (as in Al's soul must be there for the body to return from the gate). Ed is then swallowed by the hands reaching out from the Gate of Truth, and he, Envy, and Ling fall out of Gluttony's stomach, and in front of the Homunculi's "Father," who bears a startling resemblance to their own.

Unable to fight "Father", because somehow their alchemy was sealed, Ed and Al helped Scar and Mei Chang to escape but stayed behind, knowing they wouldn't be harmed by him or the Homunculi because they are still useful to them. They were sent to meet King Bradley, who told them to stay out of their affairs, if they wanted to guarantee Winry's safety, but also agreed to let them continue their search for a way to restore their bodies.

Intrigued by the fact that his alchemy was nullified by "Father", but Scar and Mei Chang's were not, Ed concludes that it must be because their alchemy has a different origin than his. He decides to look for a way to obtain knowledge about foreign alchemy.
*

Toiea


D_Marx

PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2006 9:14 am


[-cuteandbeloved-]
Well the person who said that is lying. I mean...take the anime fruits basket, its all done but a manga series is still coming out. So don't worry, the new one will come out soon.


Technically it wasn't finished because one of the voice actors decided to leave and they thought it better to discontinue the series than replace him.
PostPosted: Wed Sep 06, 2006 1:59 pm


D_Marx
[-cuteandbeloved-]
Well the person who said that is lying. I mean...take the anime fruits basket, its all done but a manga series is still coming out. So don't worry, the new one will come out soon.


Technically it wasn't finished because one of the voice actors decided to leave and they thought it better to discontinue the series than replace him.
Who left?

Scar_the_Ishbalian

6,500 Points
  • Bunny Spotter 50
  • Bunny Hunter 100
  • Bunny Hoarder 150

Kyoukage

PostPosted: Thu Sep 07, 2006 6:39 pm


I use readmanga too, and have been on ch. 59 for forever! I was just hoping they weren't dead. I love the manga.
PostPosted: Fri Sep 08, 2006 12:39 pm


i dont really like the manga...i dunno why. i just dont like how the story is going. it doesnt go with the anime. i know that good in some ways but i really dont like it.

Shyao_Sorceress

Magnetic Reveler

5,350 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Wall Street 200

Kyoukage

PostPosted: Thu Sep 14, 2006 12:30 pm


All is well. Chapters 60-62 are out, just not out on readmanga or any other site I can find. So yeah, to those that can access them, I hate you. rofl Just kidding but not really.
PostPosted: Fri Sep 15, 2006 4:56 pm


the 8th came out

Naeu


dakatsu

PostPosted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 2:20 pm


just read ch. 63 today whee . it's still coming out on time as far as i can see.
PostPosted: Sun Sep 17, 2006 2:31 pm


dakatsu
just read ch. 63 today whee . it's still coming out on time as far as i can see.

Where do you live, like state wise. The way things are going here, I'm not getting anything.

Kyoukage


Hiro_Taurus

PostPosted: Fri Sep 22, 2006 6:36 pm


The manga is Okay... I like the anime better... jeez usually it's the other way round but lately it's I like the anime!
Reply
The Full Metal Alchemist Official guild

 
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum