Welcome to Gaia! ::

Well which races are you disallowing? Obviously if the Q were included then Star Trek wins. Are you thinking of including the Humans, Klingons, Vulcans, which other ones am I missing?

Are the Jedi included in this fight? While they might not be able to make much of a dent in individual casualties their foresight could be a major advantage in battle planning.

Yes, all the SW factions will get full use of any Force users they employ.

Obviously no contest. SW will win.

Besides, even if Q were to be thrown in, the Federation can't count on him for anything; he'd just as well help the Republic instead.

Spock will reason with everyone using his flawed logic, Captain Kirk will hook up with every girl he meets leaving the SW crew seriously low on morale, thus losing the war.

Now for a serious argument. SW wins. Clone troopers, Jedi, frikkin Death Star, and a level or clairvoyance to know where to hit? It's a no-brainer.

The Q are extremely fickle beings; they're just as likely to wipe out the Federation along with the Empire.

There are all sorts of problems regarding time travel that I'll just sum it up with these three words: causality and isolation.

The Q are indeed inconsequential for the purposes of this debate.

Compared to SW hyperdrives, ST warp drives are extremely sluggish. It takes Voyager years to travel across a single quadrant of the galaxy, yet the average Imperial-class Star Destroyer can make the same trip in mere hours.

Transporters can be disrupted by all sorts of phenomena, such as ECM, deflector shields, and ambient radiation. You can't beam a bunch of Federation commandos onto a Star Destroyer or Death Star; sensory jammers would prevent Federation transporter operators from finding safe destinations for their people to beam in, ambient radiation would throw off sensor readings and further stymie their efforts, and shields would simply block them altogether.

The Borg can adapt, but only to a certain extent; a cube can withstand an assault from a single Fed ship, but not from dozens of them. Heck, even simple space debris can smash a cube to smithereens; we've also seen Species 8472 deal with the Borg in their own special way. The drones themselves aren't anything special; sure, they can shrug off phaser shots, but they can't stand up to bat'leths and Thompson SMGs. A gang of Gamorreans with vibro-axes could slice through a squad of drones with ease; a few Royal Guards with force pikes and thermal detonators can just as easily make short work of an entire battalion of drones.

The Vulcans couldn't hold up a candle to the entire Yuuzhan Vong race, even if they tried; considering that the Vong have been at war for millenia, they've had lots of time to perfect their strategies and tactics. The Chiss and Mon Calamari also deserve some credit; they did produce some of SW's greatest tactical and strategic geniuses, after all.

Captain Picard, I served with Thrawn. I knew Thrawn. Thrawn was a friend of mine. Jean-Luc Picard, you are no Mitth'raw'nuruodo. Speaking of which, Riker's no Admiral Ackbar either.