Casey's confession might as well have been a sledgehammer, for it hit Bev with the same blunt, traumatic force of one. Her expression shifted from warm, open sincerity to cold, guarded distance, and if her emotional barriers had manifested themselves in reality, Casey would have seen them shoot up around her like the trunks of dying trees, concealing and protecting her from harm. Contrary to her confrontational personality, Bev's first instinct when faced with an emotional crisis was to retreat. Like an armored tortoise, she withdrew into her shell where it was dark, quiet, and safe, leaving her aggressor to deal with her stony exterior. She should have known better than to bear her heart to someone she scarcely knew. Every time she tried, she ended up bleeding everywhere as though she'd been run through with a knife. It had happened with Charlie, someone she thought she could trust—someone she thought she could love—and it was happening again.
Bev felt sick to her stomach. Her face had become eerily apathetic, but her honest eyes radiated hurt, anguish, and disbelief, as if she couldn’t comprehend the horror of what Casey had told her. The realization that Casey was capable of lying was not a pleasant one. Above all, Bev cherished the girl’s ability to tell the truth like it was something to be desired. Bev understood her reasons for keeping her sister’s identity a secret, but why had she thought it necessary to lie when approached about the subject as opposed to telling the truth from the start? That, above all, was what hurt Bev the most. She didn’t understand why she was constantly fed partial truths and concealed lies. Was she really so unbearable that not even her friends felt comfortable opening up to her? Was it because she was a police officer—or rather—a former police officer? Regardless of her job title (or lack thereof), she was a person, and she appreciated being treated as such. She had allowed herself to sympathize with Casey’s loss, revealing a painful aspect of her life that she rarely—if ever—revealed to anyone, only to discover that her sympathy had been unrequited since its conception. Knowing that she’d been willingly led to mourn the death of Casey’s sister on false grounds made her so angry that she wanted to take a swing at the redhead herself. But, she didn’t. Instead, she turned her back to Casey and ran her fingertips over her scarred lips, saying nothing.
So close. She’d been so close to breaking ground with Casey. After going it alone for so many years, she thought she’d finally found someone to confide in, someone to feel something for without fear of being betrayed, abandoned, or used. Now she was back to square one. As badly as she wanted to turn to Casey and say, “Ya know what? It's fine. Let’s have some breakfast,” she couldn’t bring herself to do so. In addition to withholding the truth from Bev until she felt it was convenient, Casey had no idea what Big Red had put her through. It was like she was trapped in some sort of twisted, sadistic nightmare; the one person who had started to make her feel like a human being again was identical to the one who had virtually destroyed her with a single command. A bitter, wounded shred of Bev’s consciousness whispered to her from a dark corner of her mind, questioning whether or not she could have been spared such horrible torment if Casey had done something differently in her youth. The brunette was disgusted with herself for even thinking such a thing; none of this was Casey’s fault, and she knew it. Regardless, her brain had started swimming with ‘what ifs,’ and she took a seat on the couch to counteract the rush of lightheadedness that had washed over her. Resting her elbows on her knees, she keeled over and buried her forehead in her palms, shaking her head in misery as muttered incoherently through her fingers.
“Why didn’t ya tell me?”
What if Casey had stopped Big Red from entering the gang? What if she’d tried harder to reach out to her sister? Would any of it have made a difference? Bev wished she knew, but none of it mattered in the end. What was done was done, and there was point in dwelling on a past that couldn’t be changed. Getting upset at Casey for something she had or hadn't done years prior to meeting Bev was ridiculous, and Bev knew it. Besides, the former guardswoman could tell that Casey was in just as much pain as she was. Still, in spite of everything, Casey had something that Bev didn’t: a living, breathing sibling. Bev couldn’t pretend that she wasn't annoyed at Casey for taking her sister's life for granted. Hell, she would have given almost anything for the privilege of having Michael back. As long as Charlotte was alive, there was still hope. Bev found a crude, cosmic irony in the realization that her survivalist instinct had only been born because of Big Red.
“I’ve already been hurt, Casey. There’s no stoppin’ that. An’ I know who yer sister is.”
Lifting her head, Bev looked dismally up at Casey, the subtle lines creasing her face appearing more evident in the wake of the emotional exhaustion that was settling over her. Raising her right hand and turning it slowly so that Casey could see where something had been jammed through her palm and out the other side, she sighed.
“Wasn’t her hand that did this, but it might as well ‘ave been. And now she’s back. They’re both back. Hunting us down like a pack o’ wolves, most likely.”
Sometimes, Bev wished she could be a robot so that she didn’t have to feel. It would be so much easier to deal with emotions if she could sort through them like a machine; systematically, mathematically, and objectively. Unfortunately, emotions were never objective. They were messy, complicated, and made no sense whatsoever. She had only just started recovering from the tournament’s aftermath and the loss of her job, and now she had to comfort and protect Casey from the evils of her own flesh and blood. She didn’t know if she could handle everything life was throwing at her on her own, and as much as she wanted to reach out for help, she wasn’t convinced that she could trust Casey to shoulder the other half of the burden. She’d done it alone long enough. She didn’t need help. She’d just do what she always did; suffer in silence while she fell apart, piece by piece, until there was nothing left. She closed her eyes.
“I can’t do this again. I can’t let them get you, too.”