About

myOtaku FF.net


Rurouni Kenshin concluding stories: Yahiko no Sakabatou Haru ni Sakura

As a Kenshin fan who has read the manga, I can say without a doubt that Seisouhen is the most heinous betrayal of a manga by its anime counterpart that I've ever seen. The manga has a happy ending, where Kenshin stays with his wife and raises his child. There is never any mention of him leaving again to wander, getting a disease or any of this other garbage.

Everything in this OVA beyond Kenshin giving Yahiko his sword is filler and is in no way canon. The characters are bastardized beyond words. Kenshin becoming a deadbeat dad and negligent husband, Kaoru as this whiny, weepy woman who tells him it's OK to walk out on her and their son and "walk the spiritual path of atonement" and that she'll "wait as long as she has to" for him to return and then when he does return, asks him to infect her with his disease so she can follow him into death. Yeah, right! Really in character, really canon!

The background animation is well done, to be fair. But the characters themselves! They all have these weird, sunken, haggard features. Their eyes have no emotion in them. Kaoru's eyes are brown! What's up with that?

The supposed animation of the Jinchuu Arc is such a ripoff, it doesn't deserve to be called that. If it's the Jinchuu Arc, where are Gein, Banjin, Kujirinami, Otowa and Mumyoi? Where's the doll? Why doesn't Kenshin go to Rakuninmura? Where are all the others when Kenshin goes to the island to get Kaoru? They're not there because all of that, and thus the whole meaning of the story, was butchered out!

Kenshin's fight with Enishi is complete crap too. Kenshin actually allows Enishi to kick his face into the dirt and offers his life in exchange for Kaoru's? I can look through all my manga volumes and say that that is most definitely not canon!

It seems like the message of this OVA is Kenshin was never able to let go of his grief and guilt over Tomoe, Kaoru never gained the strength and resolve needed to keep Kenshin stable and that Kenshin became self-destructive after giving the Sakabatou to Yahiko. Again, I can look through my manga volumes and say that this is not canon.

This OVA betrays the message of Watsuki's manga, which is that one can best atone for one's sins by living instead of dying. The message of the OVA is that peace can only be found through death. Uh-huh. Really canon. My only prayer is that someday the real Jinchuu Arc will be animated and this betrayal, this blasphemy will pick up dust on the shelves.[/b]

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.

Journal

The Handsome Hitokiri


Ken wa kyoki. Kenjutsu wa satsujinjutsu. Donna kiregoto ya odaimaku wo kuchi nishite mo sore wa shinjitsu. Kaoru-dono no iterukoto wa ichido mo ono re no te wo kekashita koto ganai monogaiu, amatsu choroi zare goto de gozaru. Kerdomo sessha wa sonna shinjitsu yorimo Kaoru-dono no iu ama choroi zaregotgo hou ga suki de gozaru yo.

Lunaescence page MySpace TokyoPop Yahoo 360 myOtaku Minitokyo FF.net

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.

Under cover of night, the handsome, red-haired hitokiri comes up behind his prey and strikes. Never a sound is heard.


Multimedia

Comments

Viewing 10 of 20 comments.

nekochanninja211

Report | 08/14/2014 4:33 am

nekochanninja211

I'm with you! I want a real Jinchuu Arc! Not that crap OAV that I refuse to watch! Watsuki himself said in an interview how upset he was with what was made. He comments that from the first day he started Kenshin, he insisted it was to have a HAPPY ending!
Jayce Reinhardt

Report | 01/17/2014 9:20 am

Jayce Reinhardt

Your avatar and profile win the interwebz. heart
Juillet Matin

Report | 11/07/2013 2:25 pm

Juillet Matin

Your avi fills my heart with rainbows. (And I was unaware that there was more than one person here who hates how some people treat Tomoe.)
Kyathist

Report | 10/12/2013 11:47 am

Kyathist

Well done on the avatar!
RadiantFlare

Report | 07/27/2013 8:03 pm

RadiantFlare

This one loves your profile and avatar, that I do. heart ^.^x
iBeLazy

Report | 07/15/2013 7:11 pm

iBeLazy

Who is the anime character you got spammed all over your profile?
Blood Valkyrie

Report | 01/31/2012 1:40 pm

Blood Valkyrie

Thank you. heart
rahna

Report | 07/16/2011 9:51 pm

rahna

Nice profile, I love it.

Yaaaaaaay Rurouni Kenshin!! (I saw your Fanfiction profile. Saw "Sword Heart" and thought "Kenshin!" wink
BuckyKattLove

Report | 03/20/2011 5:49 pm

BuckyKattLove

Aha. That's the best description for it I've ever heard. XD
Yes! I concur. 3nodding
BuckyKattLove

Report | 03/18/2011 9:08 pm

BuckyKattLove

I like to pretend Seishouen (I can never remember the proper spelling) doesn't even exist. scream
A decent animated version of Jinchuu would be awesome. 3nodding It's nice to see someone who agrees with me. smile

Signature

Stop SOPA 2014
"However strong, a hitokiri isn't ever the real thing. His is a lonely sword that leaves only regret behind."
User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. click to show.