Guild, I need help deciding.

[Bunny Motherof2]

the first one  

[Lural]

The first one reminds me of Chinese checkers.

The second is more unique. I prefer the second  

[Song Phox Young]

I think it depends on how much you want to emphasize the Star of David.  

[Xelliah]

I like the 2nd one ^^  

[GuenivereOrion]

i like the first one  

[Zphal]

Song Phox Young

I think it depends on how much you want to emphasize the Star of David.

Well, that it be semi-Hanukkah themed is important to me.  

[Zphal]

Guenivere ORion

i like the first one

Xelliah

I like the 2nd one ^^

Lural

The first one reminds me of Chinese checkers.

The second is more unique. I prefer the second

Bunny Motherof2

the first one

Thanks for all of your input! heart  

[evesse]

The first option.  

[Song Phox Young]

Zphal

Song Phox Young

I think it depends on how much you want to emphasize the Star of David.

Well, that it be semi-Hanukkah themed is important to me.

Then I think you should should go with the first emblem. It is also more symmetrical, and thus more appealing, compared to the second. Also, the bolder lines speak louder and give it stronger but smoother feel. It captures more, I think. (I realized this upon a second examination). That's my opinion, anyhow.  

[puppylove713]

I like the first one the best.  

[petez4]

Zphal

petez4

I like the first one better.

Thanks for the input! Also, I'm lovin' your purple-y avatar. biggrin

Thanks! 4laugh  

[musasgal]

I prefer the second pattern.  

[Zphal]

KatyaChekov

First one, I like the additional Magen David in the middle there.

Yeah, if I tried put a cut-out one in the second pattern, it would be very large... but otherwise it's too small. So I had to do a hexagon. Thanks!  

[Zphal]

Song Phox Young

Zphal

Song Phox Young

I think it depends on how much you want to emphasize the Star of David.

Well, that it be semi-Hanukkah themed is important to me.

Then I think you should should go with the first emblem. It is also more symmetrical, and thus more appealing, compared to the second. Also, the bolder lines speak louder and give it stronger but smoother feel. It captures more, I think. (I realized this upon a second examination). That's my opinion, anyhow.

An excellent analysis. 3nodding Thanks for your input! 4laugh