Welcome to Gaia! :: What would you stop your kids from reading ?

Log In

Forgot your login?

Sign Up

Register
 
GST
Tags: would  stop  your  kids  from 
Export this topic to other sites using WildFire!
forum:15, topic:40286895
< 1 2 3 4 ... 9 10 11 >
"Risu the Troll"
I read Gormenghast when I was eleven and it did wonders for my interest in the language. I now have two friends who are struggling through it at twenty. If they'd been given more opportunity when they were younger, reading such mature books might not be such a chore now.


But then, I don't think there are too many eleven year-olds who're interested in books like Gormenghast. At that age my parents would've needed to force me to read it. Would've found it boring then, still find it boring now. I think it's safe to say you were a rather developed reader at a rather young age to begin with, so you don't really count as part of the majority. Sometimes it's just a matter of taste rather than of missed opportunity.

As far as adult content goes, though, I don't consider Gormenghast all that bad --- nothing gratuitous as far as I'm concerned. If my eleven year-old kid expressed an interest in reading it, I wouldn't have any problems with it. Hell, any eleven year-old who would actually want to read something like that is probably mature enough to read it anyway.
 
     
I'm not a garbage man, damn it. I'm a trick-or-treating cyclops dressed as Luigi.
 
I would probably give them a talk once my kid wants to read horror or anything that's really explicit. A good decent talk along with some novelists along the lines of the author's writing style. I would tell them WHAT is inside the book but I would try to not enforce my opinion on the books strongly.

I am too young to think about Parenting. I am possibly the one girl in town who isn't trying to get pregnant at sixteen or party like a wild child, so it makes me go Gonk when I am given a baby to hold. I am afraid I would drop the child or make the child scared of me. I am not good with kids. sweatdrop
     

HAI GUYZ IT'S EDWARD! I BIT U, K?

Don't stand so close to me. Roxanne... I can't stand losing you.

>.>

Message in a bottle.

405/5000 cans left!
dah fuzzinator of dewm!
The way I look at it is, "If my child can't see a movie about this sort of stuff why should they read about it?" So... if my son or daughter was not allowed to watch Fight Club why would I even let them near Chuck Pahlniuk and so on and so forth.

I don't think I'd be the type of parent that freaks out over swear words, but there are some topics that are too mature for a child to read. A twelve year old might be able to read I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings but I'm not sure I'd want them to because of the part where Maya is raped.
 
     
If every n00b who entered the arena just gave that 1k to me I'd be a very happy woman.

Currently questing: Celestial Wrap 2k/18k - Donations accepted and appreciated.
Thank you Mischief Dragon for help with my White Drome quest!
 

If in fifteen, twenty years or so I find myself with a child who is of an age where they've become able to comprehend novels, and have a desire to read something that would raise eyebrows. I'd let them.
Hell, I'd let them read anything they want - whether it be of literary value, or be utter crap, or if it be children's silliness, or mature material.

Reason? They'd be READING. Of their own free will, even. I think a lot of us here aren't as cognizant of the way things are going with modern youth as we should be. My sister is all of four years younger than me, and she RARELY reads anything more substantial than Gossip Girl or the latest Meg Cabot novel [although, I'll admit that I too find her books to be amusing. If your only experience with the Princess Diaries is that massacrization* of a Disney movie, you might find yourself pleasantly amused by how absolutely sadistic the books are.] The rub here? She is probably the BEST read out of anyone in her social group.

The times they are a changin', and though books survived the MTV generation, and hang on by a strand in the Internet generation, no one knows how they'll get pushed around in the next advance.
'Course, my house will always be full of books, so there'll never be any lack of availability should my child choose to read.


*I'll be submitting that word for approval by all major dictionaries this year. At gunpoint. <3
Feel free to use it as you will.
     
Formerly Seth Regente, who is now retired.

Vaguely-linked-to-writing-blog
http://terrabyterd.blogspot.com/
Bad Poetry
http://allpoetry.com/StillbornSonofMan


I wish I cared less.
"Indigo Dagger"
Cats can't read. So I would have no problem there.


My cats like to read birthday cards....XD

Anyways I wouldn't let my kinds read anything that had mature content until they were in middle school. Hopefully before that they wouldn't want to read books like that before then.
 
     
Kaorihiddeninthecookies
 
I'd let them read whatever they wanted, really. I was reading Battletech and Forgotten Realms books when I was 11 and 12. I didn't realize it then, but it did wonders for my vocabulary.

Then again, I never ever ever want to reproduce.
     
http://card.mygamercard.net/marble/green/Intended+Chaos.png

Add me; just let me know you're from Gaia! surprised

http://urlcut.com/1bwwh
"FISHIExCORE"
God have mercy on any children of mine.

Honestly, I have no idea. I'm not a parent, I'm paralyzed at the very idea of being a parent, I'm a terrible enough influence on my nieces and nephews. I have no idea how I'd handle having children and how I'd go about overseeing (if at all) their literary development in that respect.

I'm right there too.

However, if I do find myself with a child (or three as people are trying to curse me with not one, but three drool-factories) I would encourage reading. They would only have one-hundredth the amount of toys my niece and nephew have (which would leave them with about 15 at any given time), but there would be no limit on the number of books, magazines, and other reading material they may want. Movies would also be limited, as would the selection of channels on the TV (that's assuming I even have a TV in my home once I move out).

I wouldn't limit what they read either. If they feel they can handle reading a large piece of literature like War and Peace I'll let them. If they prefer to stick to silly YA novels, I'd let them. Why? Because either way they are reading! I would challenge them to read something out of their comfort zone on occasion, simply because I wouldn't want them to become boxed in in their mindset of the world. I would probably make it a habit for them to read the news at least once a week to keep in touch with the goings-on of the world.

I want my children to have an imagination. I want them to value reading as much as I do and to explore their own creativity. Whether that creativity comes out in the form of writing like myself, painting, or hell even music, I'd be happy. I don't want my children to grow up and become illiterate fools who can't comprehend the simplest of things.
 
     
 
I would put small limits on books... like nothing with excessive amounts of violence or swearing, but other than that... I might keep them from reading badly written books unless they really insist on reading them.

Nothing more, though. I would have to be a responsible parent but I'm not going to limit the expansion of their minds, either.
     
You should never stop your children from reading.
I don't think I could ever limit kids from reading, even if I don't agree with what it is, its their choice to read it.
 
     
 
Well for me it's kind of complicated. I mean there are a lot of books out there that don't do any justice to what my children will be... so many crappy characters put in even shittier positions and roles. I'll let them read whatever, but I will also explain to them why it is these are annoying craptastic shadows of themselves.
     
Quote:
Man... I never thought I'd see the day a bunch of trolls would play fantasy plantation owner in an African American forum... must be trolling.

:'D . D':
Let me see...my fiance and I both read a lot. He has been reading things like The Lord of the Rings and Dune from the seventh grade, and I just read all over the board regardless of the age range or reputation of the book. We plan on our son waking up at the age of ten and finding a copy of Dune on his bedstand.

That aside, I also plan on having a rule that if they want to watch a movie and they have the book the movie is based on, I'll take them to see it only if they read the book first.

I feel that violence and other things in books are different than they are in movies. In a lot of ways, they are worse because it is in your head and not on the screen, but things happen. Sex, I'm not worried about. It is a necessary part of life. Violence happens. I won't get upset about them reading about killing.

I will provide them with copies of the Kuran, the Torah, the Bible, the Satanic Bible, my personal book of shadows, and any other text they want as far as religion is concerned because that will be their choice.

Dianetics, on the other hand, is a very seductive book and something I would keep well hidden until they were old enough to handle it. I don't want my future offspring caught up in scientology, but hopefully I'll have taught them more sense than that by the time they're old enough to know.
 
     
 
I don't really intend to have children, but they will be smacked headfirst into the Infinite Wall of Knowledge if they do end up existing. I joked about reading them ATOTC as infants, but knowing me I totally would.

Anyway, long story short I plan on converting my house into a huge a** library filled to the cieling with books, so, I can't really stop them, can I?

(I do kind of want to preserve my kids innocence though. I mean, I'm really appauled by the way my peers act nowadays, and I totally sound like an crotchety old woman. And I'd prefer them reading about sex than violence. I'll never understand why the US hates sex but loves violence. Seems backwards to me.)
     
RAWR.
Like most of the previous posters, I don't know whether or not I'll actually have kids to stop reading anything, but I'm taking as a model my own childhood: I'll let them read just about anything, as long as they seem ready for it. I'll do my best to encourage them to read "real" literature rather than "YA fiction," but honestly, you know what? In elementary school, I read YA fiction by the busload, and it didn't stop me from reading nonfiction and biographies and wanting to be Sherlock Holmes (when I didn't want to be Clint Eastwood's characters; we watched a lot of Westerns in my house). Obviously I'm not letting them near certain texts, and I'm not going to be handing any book containing genocide, rape, or religious extremism to a preschooler... but the kid-or-kids will know what kind of books they want to read, and hopefully I'll be in-tune enough to know what those books are, rather than making arbitrary decisions based on my own experiences and my ideas of what I think my kids might be.

The one exception I'll make to the above will probably be anything that presents a particularly appealing view-point with the guide to living it in real-life. The above-mentioned Dianetics, anything espousing a specific way of "living your personal freedoms," and Ayn Rand would be candidates, just because they're easy to be swayed by when you don't have enough experience to see the flaws; I'd try to make sure my children would be able to distinguish "neat new idea that kind of makes sense (or not)" from "ZOMG this is how I want to LIVE." Hopefully my children won't be quite so impressionable, but everyone can make some pretty poorly-informed decisions, so I'd limit resources like those until they're mature/level-headed enough to not drop what they're doing and start preaching the virtues of _____. The same would go for most religions/philosophies, but "mainstream" ideas usually aren't "cool" enough to warrant sudden conversion.

But honestly, as mentioned, I'll be just as happy having a normal kid. That is, even if they want to read Harry Potter or the Boxcar Children at age 8, fine! They're eight and they're reading, which is enough. And if they hit their preteens and start reading that YA vampire/faerie novels, then... Well, I guess it still counts as reading, and it's probably just a phase. The main thing I'd try to do is provide them with reading materials irregardless of what those materials are; it'll probably be less "I forbid you to read Mein Kampf!" and more "Teen Beat instead of The Smithsonian? Well, as you're 12, I guess I'll let it slide... but that subscription comes out of your own allowance."
 
     
Silver Revolver: 7,000 Tickets
Bullet Belts: 6,900 Tickets
Total: 13,900 Tickets

22/13,900

Please donate?

(Tokens & gold for tokens also welcome.)
 
"Nefas Fatum"
Cory Ander, I admire your positive outlook on life and raising children. Here's hoping that you get the children you want and that they are as honest with you as you believe they will be.

Now, whilst I'm sure we all agree that the TV isn't the best of babysitters, I'd like to bring up the fact that technology moved at incredible speeds and since the beginning of the pc in the '70's to now, we have left a lot of the older generation behind. The change happened too fast for them. Can we really blame them for not realising that games have ratings on them?

When the local schools offer classes for the parents to familiarise themselves with computers and the internet, then I'm sorry, I can't blame the parents for not realising what their kids are getting into. It's not bad parenting that makes them computer iliterate, it's the fact that they did not grow up with computers the way their kids are doing now.

Also, whilst you believe you can control what a 13yr old can and can't read, we live in an age where girls mature physically a lot younger than they used to and once those hormones kick in, your job as a parent and controlling what they want to read/look at becomes a lot harder.

I'll stick with my opinion from earlier, freedom of information is a great thing and what I believe in is not something I will take away from my kids.


Being computer illiterate is no excuse. I started using the internet when I was elven and my mother knew the websites I went on to. She can't use a computer to this day and has to call me and ask me computer based questions. She simply payed attention to where I went on the computer. The computer was kept in a spot where she could easily see me and thus could look at my screen if I was on any mistrusting site. She might not know the mechanics of what I was doing but she could recognize if something was bad.

Also the advancement of technology is also no excuse for not knowing games have ratings. Anyone with a brain should be able to hear "Grand Theft Auto" or "Resident Evil" and know something might be mature. Also, they might not know it has a rating but you can see the rating on the front of a game and on the back. What about reading a games description before buying it for a child. I mean I'm looking at my Assassin's Creed right now and the rating is on the front, back and even on the disk itself.

Parent's are lazy these days. They don't know what their kids like and don't even try to understand. I mean these days parents find any way to simply get rid of their kids.

When I have children I am going to make sure that I am part of their life. If they're thirteen and want to read the likes of the Vampire Chronicles then I'll let them. As long as they're not like most of the immature idiots I see running around these days.

I'm not saying I'm going to restrict what my child reads and censor things. I just won't let them read something harmful for them. I mean I won't let a ten year old read A Clockwork Orange. However when they're a bit older and more mature I'll encourage them to read it. For me it's about knowing what a child is mentally prepared for.

I mean really if I am any kind of good parent then my children shouldn't be going for things I do not want them to.
     
They would not be allowed to read Animorphs, for sure. Really, anything I deem to be mind rotting is out. Other than that, they want to pick up a Steven King book at age seven, be my guest, but they better not come crying to me when they get nightmares.
 
     

Ban all the music with a phony gas chamber cause one's got a weasel and others got a flag, one's on the pole, shove the other in the bag.
< 1 2 3 4 ... 9 10 11 >