The Phoenix Rises Again
The Phoenix Rises Again
My problem: Any name that sounds like 'Pyre?'
Along with problem, I want to know what people think about a girl with white hair named Frost.
At your first one: I would go with Nathaniel/it's Feminine variant if you're going for a fire motif (Nathaniel being the Angel of Fire). Blatantly meaningful names only really work well in the last name, otherwise it feels contrived and far too convenient.
Which leads me to your second query: No. It's a horrible name for a girl in general. Why on earth would a parent name their daughter that? Frost is a surname - and comes off very contrived in that it is just TOO obvious. Even if it's an ironic name, just no.
Problem I see here is that you're trying to take an Asian style pun - that a character's signature X happens to share a kanji/symbol/whatever with a character in the character's given name - and make it work in English.
It doesn't. At all.