Books good. Movies terrible

[10_Ace_of_Spades]

I sort of liked the books. Meyers has an interesting way of writing. Hated the movies though. Any others that agree?

[Crazy Valentine]

I think I'm the opposite, though I haven't actually watched the whole movies yet, or read all the books yet. But Meyer is just a horrible writer, I mean, seriously, who wants a mopey girl that does nothing but complain.

[The Carnivorous Unicorn]

Omg u need 2 stop hatin on Twilite11

[Scoot McCallMeMaybe]

Me Tarzan, you Jane. (what's up with the title...?)

The books were horrible for me. If I never read the books I would like the movies. I watched the first movie, read the books right around when New Moon came out and I just hated it ever since. I couldn't stand being in Bella's head.

[Alexander J Luthor]

I disagree. The movies weren't that good at all, but they're far better than the movies.

[personwholikescookiezX3]

Nope. The books were horrible, but the movies were slightly better as I didn't have to listen to her describe Edward every other sentence.

[TheQuietRiversRage]

I'm the opposite as well. I watched the movies and liked them more because they had a better mix of vantage points. Sure, they still lull too much on Bella and Edward, but they were tolerable. I've yet to finish 1 book because I am not Bella and hate having to be in her shadow when reading. Especially since I want to slap her.

[Tympest]

I rather disliked the books and have not taken the time to see the movies, but unless they had a constant voice over of KStew as Bella describing Edward constantly they cannot be as bad as the books.

[Destined Savior]

How is Meyer's style of writing interesting? It's too drawn out and purpley prosey to even be that good.

Honestly, I think half the time I just gave up caring and just read the book because I wanted to.

[Shibuyakouzorinanamushi]

No you got it all wrong. Movies are better because you don't need to read Bella's constant Whining and Bitching and her non-stop thought of Edward.

[Astra Ironwolf]

They both have their good points. I kind of liked that we got to see more of the non-Bella/Edward/Jacob characters in the movies.

[Shibuyakouzorinanamushi]

Astra Ironwolf

They both have their good points. I kind of liked that we got to see more of the non-Bella/Edward/Jacob characters in the movies.

It won't be called Twilight if it wasn't base on Bella/Edward/Jacob. It will be like a shitty spin-off that no one care.

[Astra Ironwolf]

Thrun teh magical cat

Astra Ironwolf

They both have their good points. I kind of liked that we got to see more of the non-Bella/Edward/Jacob characters in the movies.

It won't be called Twilight if it wasn't base on Bella/Edward/Jacob. It will be like a shitty spin-off that no one care.

a) Nothing in the word "Twilight" explicitly implies that a story titled "Twilight" must be based on characters named Bella, Edward, and Jacob. If the series were titled, "Bella, Edward and Jacob's Super Smexy Fun Tiems!", then you'd be correct.
b) I didn't say that the movies shouldn't be based around Bella/Edward/Jacob. I merely said that I enjoyed seeing more of the ancillary characters. They add extra flavor to the story.
c) As far as I know, being civil to people that you disagree with hasn't killed anyone. Try it sometime.

[Shibuyakouzorinanamushi]

Astra Ironwolf

Thrun teh magical cat

Astra Ironwolf

They both have their good points. I kind of liked that we got to see more of the non-Bella/Edward/Jacob characters in the movies.

It won't be called Twilight if it wasn't base on Bella/Edward/Jacob. It will be like a shitty spin-off that no one care.

a) Nothing in the word "Twilight" explicitly implies that a story titled "Twilight" must be based on characters named Bella, Edward, and Jacob. If the series were titled, "Bella, Edward and Jacob's Super Smexy Fun Tiems!", then you'd be correct.
b) I didn't say that the movies shouldn't be based around Bella/Edward/Jacob. I merely said that I enjoyed seeing more of the ancillary characters. They add extra flavor to the story.
c) As far as I know, being civil to people that you disagree with hasn't killed anyone. Try it sometime.

A) Twilight is base on Bella's life story.
b) No one gives a s**t about the other minors' stories.
c) Your last argument is invalid. I don't have to respect you nor your opinion.

[blackheartgirl2]

Books are always better than the movies. I didn't even watch the movies because the trailers seemed too different from the books.