His Paper Princess
This makes me sad. I hate trying to anon in such large threads, I prefer finding the smaller ones and stalking those. I have a feeling I won't be doing much this event. ):
It's okay. If you keep track of you who you gift - say, a username on a notepad file with some way to tell who got a gift and who didn't will be helpful in deciding who you want to gift.
Also, you may not know this, but if you look at a person's post history, you can tell if that person deserves a gift or not.