People are allowed to enjoy a movie for more than one thing (plot and attractive characters, for example)
Rants about decisions made to draw in an audience (ie: creating characters/romance out of thin air) that may or may not have viewed the movie otherwise aren't really a part of the topic of this thread. That's a topic that should be in its own thread. Not to say that the point isn't valid, its just not a part of this thread.
This thread is about the attractive characters in the movie, which may or may not be exclusive to a person's enjoyment of the movie.
I personally think that Fili is the more attractive of the two... ^^; Yes, Kili is very attractive, but he's kind of not Dwarf-y enough, and that made me keep thinking he was just some sort of short human. :p And so Fili jumped to the top of the list. Also, I love his braids, his beard, and its accoutrements. *lol*