OCGuardians
Uhm, thanks for the comment? My two cents:
Dressage = Abuse - Rolkur, over straining/extending the natural movements of horses, breeds do not matter they are all the same species - equine. Favored bits for dressage can snap a horse's jaw easily, as with any sport using the same bits.
Jumping - high speeds and tight turns don't mix, again, bits are a hazard as are the terrains used and equipment.
Cross Country - More natural to the horse, bits are a problem.
Racing - Horses drugged, beaten to run for money; thrown away(slaughter, abandonment) when not useable anymore. = ABUSE
I'm a owner who supports natural horse riding, (aka no bits - I wouldn't want a device made purposely to cause me pain for obedience in my mouth. No shoes, it does not allow to hoof to flex, hence circulation loss.) I've done my research, and witnessed my proof. Truely listen to your horse and they'll be happier to please you.
"I can't expect a 1200+ lb. animal to move if I just touch them with my leg, there has to be pressure applied and inadequate muscling is just going to leave you exhausted and your horse sloppy looking."
I don't need pressure, mine move off the slightest touch because I've proved that I'm the herd leader they can trust and work with equally. Again, try going natural, it's worth it, and it's cheaper. And painless.
Its unfortunate your post sounds rather condescending when all I was aiming to do is support your notion of it being a sport. But to each his own I suppose. (It also seems to be the nature of the industry as well. Sigh.)
Of all the horses I have worked with, none have shown displeasure in the Dressage work. Perhaps I should have specified, I deal more with the Classical end of Dressage.
Rollkur has no place in a setting where people are correctly providing their horses with the fundamentals. Besides, you only see Rollkur in the upper levels (Olympics, WEG, FEI, etc.). Dressage IS one of the most natural forms of structured riding. Xenophon, the father of horsemanship also developed much of what we now consider our Dressage.
Dressage pretty plainly translates to training.
**Breeds DO matter when we are talking about conformational soundness for any desired activity.**
You cannot lump the negative things many mainstream competitors do into being the whole of a discipline. Not everyone treats their horses in a poor way just because they compete or specialize.
It's very ignorant to assume such disciplines as a whole are detrimental to the equine's over-all health.
This is why many people see Natural Horsemanship as a bunch of froofroo nonsense - people who adamantly practice it generally are the first to scream 'abuse' at any given competitive equestrian.
I will not argue in terms of barefooted-ness (All of mine have always been without shoes), aside from the few Quarter Horses with shrimpy, soft feet that fall apart once they touch anything other than grass, I'm an advocator of natural hoof health. In extreme cases, I'd rather see Epona hoofwear used, or boots such as the Cavallos.
You're lucky to have light, responsive horses. Many aren't and it's not always the current owner's fault. Majority of horses have some form of baggage.
I'm also going to go out on a limb here and assume you either a) have your horses on your home property or b) live very close by.
Many people who enjoy the sport simply do not have the time or the resources to practice NH in it's truest form. Besides, a lot of people don't actually own horses (in my area at least), majority are lease-based for competition seasons, leaving the rider powerless in the terms of the horse's training and shoe work.
I commend you for being one of the few who pursues this fully, I'm sure your horses thank you daily. Just try to appreciate the fact that not everyone outside of your NH bubble is evil and abusive to their horses.