Design feedback #5

How would rate this?

5 (it's great)	19.4%	[ 12626 ]
4	18.7%	[ 12129 ]
3 (it's okay)	23.8%	[ 15449 ]
2	14.5%	[ 9397 ]
1 (don't like it)	23.6%	[ 15354 ]
Total Votes:			[ 64955 ]

[-kawaii cherry lemons-]

This one has pretty varied votes...
But me, I hate it.
I dont know why.

[Chellies]

I like this one the best, but I think it should have some avatars or something more Gaia-related on it.

[Female Indiana Jones]

way to plain

[broken hearted angel300]

this one looks more like a gaia sort of style and its also not over doing it but its not being too plain

[stArliights]

mattmagician

Out of all of them I like this one most =D

[aiyaitsai]

a bit bland compared to the others

[Only Shimo]

I prefer this design, though I think it needs a little more color ^_^ maybe something more than just penciled art?

[Cleocatra Osiris]

It's a bit plain, but I like the focus on the forums.

[Rose Koneko]

:3 It needs a bit more color, but other than that I think this is pretty cool.

It shows off Gaia's attractions well, and it seems to be pretty neutral; you don't have to be an anime fan to love it, and you don't have to be a non-anime fan to enjoy it.

[LIL KING21]

It's Ok

[Par Exemple]

Use either this one or the mermaid one.

[Alini]

I like the different speech bubbles but there's not enough art, it's not visual enough to express Gaia fully.

[Prancing4Joy]

i like it, it not girly or guys it normal
wow i thought i well never use that word in the game but i did

[Parasynthetic]

I think I like this one best out of all of them. :3

[joyfulmusic]

Needs more graphics based on Gaia. Somehow when I look at this all I see is words, no fun.