Design feedback #5

How would rate this?

5 (it's great)	19.4%	[ 12626 ]
4	18.7%	[ 12129 ]
3 (it's okay)	23.8%	[ 15449 ]
2	14.5%	[ 9397 ]
1 (don't like it)	23.6%	[ 15354 ]
Total Votes:			[ 64955 ]

[ToxicKandyKid]

Add an avatar sample in so people get a feel of what they look like a little better. Some people won't bother if they don't know how the avatars look.

[Maramas]

This one bores me to no end.

[D all the Above]

All the quote bubbles make it look tacky. And all the colors are too bland.

[mhaksin]

sooo plain. stare

[papekonoko]

of them all, i think the mermaid one is my favorite (it pops and the colors are beautifully vibrant), but the counter really bothers me. it just doesn't gel with the rest of the design. heart

[Dewrose]

it's very simple. stare confused

[Tsuan]

I like the idea of showing different speech bubbles and that there's a community....

but it's leaving out the avatar, and that's a really big part of gaia also...try mixing both together.

[[Simply_Emi]]

I really like this one!
The whole description about Gaia's forums really does sound true.
I'm torn between this one & the second one.

[bandnerdsrool]

this one is kinda cute.. but really plain..

[smexicanchick]

its kinda too plain for me i like the mermaid better

[Lady_Orchid09]

I like it!!! heart Totally flows with the mood of gaiaonline! heart blaugh 3nodding

[angeloodevil]

i like this one

than

others..

[Phinixs]

i like this one the best

[angeljellodevil]

i like this one!it's my favorite! but it has to be a little bit more colorful! 3nodding

[numagirl22]

it`s a cool cocept,but it`s so bland!I`m all for the more gentle colors,since I have epilepsy,so therefor can`t handle sharp contrasts,but it needs some colors.I like #3 best.