Design feedback #4

How would you rate this?

5 (it's great)	13.0%	[ 8792 ]
4	16.5%	[ 11188 ]
3 (it's okay)	24.5%	[ 16563 ]
2	16.7%	[ 11292 ]
1 (don't like it)	29.3%	[ 19870 ]
Total Votes:			[ 67705 ]

[elffromspace]

The mermaid one is prettier, but I think it's important to have some actual avatar designs on the page.

[Fabled Twilight]

it doesn't appeal to me neutral

[thunder_dragonslayer]

i think the girl that they have now is better than this one

[eLot 2]

uhm not so good idea

[AhOngKia]

ugly gal stare

[iLuvChOcoLat]

i like this because its shows the true meaning of gaia but i think that the mermaid one is the best

[Projectoutlet]

Yeah, the girl almost looks sickly. Not my favorite that's for sure. I like the mermaid one the best.

[Dimont]

its ok rolleyes

[I am a Gilbert Grape]

worst one!
Wrose than the crazy rocker

[Lady Helen Smith]

Speaking as a hetro woman...


There really isnt that much wrong with her.

You people are to shallow and have too high expectations.

Tbh I think it's the pose, hair and the pout that turns people away.

She's really pretty imo.

[Natasaur]

i liked this one, but it seemed like a lot of gaians didnt... heart xxx

[Geschlechtsteile]

Significance

I don't really like it, no.
I think gaia would be best off staying away from using real life images on the homepage. They could be offensive, turn people away, or limit the target audience in some way.

Using real life pictures seems to causes too many problems for what they're worth. :)

[Tormented`Angel]

I like the concept of reinvention but I think that the background and mass of white at the bottom make the whole thing look a bit bland.

[Penthesileia]

I'm not too fond of it.

It could use more color and/or pizzazz. And don't forget, a lot of Gaians aren't in high school anymore, so the lockers make it seem like a site just for teenagers.

[the darkness of a tear]

Tis Okay..
But the girl scares me.