Design feedback #3

How would you rate this?

5 (it's great)	53.9%	[ 49102 ]
4	22.4%	[ 20410 ]
3 (it's okay)	13.0%	[ 11812 ]
2	5.2%	[ 4744 ]
1 (don't like it)	5.6%	[ 5077 ]
Total Votes:			[ 91145 ]

[snow-kitten101]

I LOVE this one! ^_^ blaugh 4laugh 3nodding

[Grimsbie]

i think you need to get rid of/change the counter P:

[-Techno Reign-]

This one is my favorite. <3

Can I has donationz? ^w^

[sadewrdfasddsdtfwretvzxc]

I like this one the best...^^

[Masco]

This one is by far my favorite one.

However, it shows a little too much that Gaia is feminine again. If you rotated this around so that it changes with the Monthly Collectables, then that'd be pretty snazzy.

[kfea82]

I heart this 1 its soooo good mermaids are so awesome i give it 10 out of 5! biggrin mrgreen heart 4laugh smile lol surprised wink razz rofl exclaim

[pugzrock]

for some reason i knew this one would be liked the most, but it dosnt "tickle my fancy", lol. it has the color i'm looking for-i'll give ya that, but it needs more color, brighter colors, and why the heck a mermaid?????? NO MERMAIDS- it has nothing to do with the wounderfulness of gaia! i think you should put some things on the home page that has to do with gaia- like gold, cool items, cool avatars, fish and whatever is actullay in gaia! i think it would be sooooooooooooo awesome if the home page was a big collage of everthing in gaia! please consider this set up!!!!! it would be so magnificent heart

[x__Shiva]

LOVE IT! mrgreen heart

[Anna Lee Ramsey]

I love the beautiful art work. Though the large counter seems a bit tacky to me.

[CrimsonButterfly3]

I love it! This is one of my favorite pictures from puzzles, so I really like how you guys have it as the background pic 3nodding

[Nyx]

It's probably my second favorite overall.

I've just seen a lot of the mermaid picture, and I'm hesitant to give it super kudos so I can see if every time I log on.

[Xynck]

Gaia should definately use its artist more. They do really well as demonstrated in the comic, on Monthly collectibles, etc. I remember when the banner was the Barton one with the guy in front and other people off to the side. I miss that one. crying

[lilrisingsun]

I really like this one as well but it seems a bit "girly" for guys so I think that the best one is the one with the 3 people and 3 on avis in the center. This one has the most colors which makes it pop.

[ken oSYa]

should change the mermaid with somethings more cool mrgreen

[Cactmoore]

I feel like this one will automatically be more popular than the others. I recall with the last change, a lot of people complained about the lightness/brightness/whiteness of the new screen (myself excepted ... I liked the white look), so assuming that people's tastes are even a little consistent, it is quite reasonable that they would pick this one over the others.
One note here: the counter of people who are online looks AWFUL. It's big, tacky, and doesn't match the style or colour scheme of ANYTHING on the rest of the page.