Design feedback #1

How would you rate this design?

5 (it's great)	22.4%	[ 17661 ]
4	22.6%	[ 17826 ]
3 (it's okay)	35.6%	[ 28101 ]
2	10.5%	[ 8334 ]
1 (don't like it)	9.0%	[ 7078 ]
Total Votes:			[ 79000 ]

[otap]

heart heart heart

This is the nicest one, and GAIA really does allow me to express myself...

heart heart heart

[Lil Angel 6194]

I do have to say i like this one for the these reasons.
It is not overfilled and very simple and right to the point,which is great and it just perfect for gaia.

[666littledevil]

i l.ike it but i dont want anything like that im sorry smile

[blader the bathog]

Its ok..pretty good.

[s0uls unit3d]

this ones my favorite

[T0fit0]

it's very simple

[Sau Rosie Vulpe]

I love it heart

[Keist]

The last time you guys experimented with the "torn/splashed edges" look, it was pretty disastrous. Don't make the same mistake twice by using this design. ):

[ButtFlap666]

i don't particularly care for it because it looks too muchl ike it could be too much like it could be the home page to neopets or something x.X

<3 xxx

[His Godless Whelp]

It's visually nice, but it seems to only target people who would enjoy submitting their art to a site to get judged.
It wouldn't have appealed to me. I think you should aim for something more generalized.

[Misz_Mani]

nothing special to me.

[Matt Lutz]

This one is my second fav and personally, I'd think its awesome

[XxCaRoL_ChAnxX]

its ok. biggrin

[Shoe Faerie]

I give it a thumbs down

[Ninja Disco Frog]

Its alright just way too kiddish.