It's about time we all get out
This is kind of outside the scope of the question, but would it be possible to compact the "All Listings" page so all items of one type have only one listing instead 23098589279233?
sweatdrop Like when you search "collectible" (not all of which are tagged, btw), all the collectibles show up neatly ordered with one listing and you follow the listing to get all the listings for that item. This would make the "All Listings" page soooooooooo much easier to use.
heart
For the question at hand: Being able to choose would be great, but if it's an either/or proposition, relevancy ftw.
and vote for love.