i love the fact that you have added so much stuff to it aver the years that i've been here but now it's in desperate need of organization. I think if you created tabs that said FLOWERS, DRINKS, CAKES, CANDIES and the like, it would be a lot easier to get to what we're looking for in the shop.
I would be so happy if they actually added categories to the shop like those suggested. Sometimes (especially during Events), I am buying gifts for the "Gift the person above you." threads, and the particular items I want to get I have to scroll through to. And although it only takes a few extra moments, it would be easier for me to just go directly to a tab instead of by chance glancing over it by mistake and then spending an extra 5 minutes trying to find the item.
...Sometimes I get a case of "Can't find s**t right in front of my face"-ness.
As a frequent customer and window shopper to the Buttercup Cafe, I know that categorization and new shop tabs would be such a time saver! Even to this day I still haven't memorized which page each thing is on. ; 3; Drinks, candies, cakes/pies, etc would do just the trick!