This is such a long debated issue.
In ways, there's many things that I still love about Gaia, but there are many things that are certainly something that could be dealt away with.
I signed up in '04 but didn't truly become very, very active until later that year, possibly around late '05--simply because I was growing out of Neopets and its childish atmosphere. I loved Gaia for it's atmosphere--simply because it was more suited for teens.
And I can remember frustrations with the past website. As an '04 member, I can certainly remember all the database errors and glitches. The site seemed so nice to me at the time. However, as it's been debated, a lot of this 'change' we see in Gaia's atmosphere. I joined when I was a mere thirteen; of course I'm going to enjoy different atmospheres now. So for that, I partially attribute it. Those discussions that once seemed so awesome to us might seem now to be something too silly.
There are defiantly some wrong decisions that Gaia made along the way, though...
When I heard about the advertising, I actually agreed. Back then, I thought 'Hey, what can a little advertising hurt? It's just to help fund the site'. I hate seeing all these advertisements around here, though, hearing about movies that I don't want to see. Most of all, the MTV. Why, oh why? This is an anime site. Not an American pop culture site. This is the one place I thought I could remove myself from that horrid thing.
To those who are pretty crude to Lanzer and other Gaia staff, I do think you need to cut them a little slack. While, yes, trying to attract so many users is pretty bad, the fact that you think that Gaia is bidding for money only for greed is a little bit of a misconception. Look at all this--Gaia has fourteen million users, and likely billions of posts. Do you know how expensive it is to maintain webspace for that many users, with games, complete with forums and hundreds of different items for avatars?
A while back, I met a girl who ran a small fan-site for an anime. No forums. Just images, character guides, music, scans, et cetera. And she ended up having to close down her website because her webhosting could run around a hundred dollars a month.
Even with an affordable provider, Gaia's bills are high. Their original intentions were all right--providing their users with gifts while they helped support the site and keep it a free service for all.
Again, it just got out of control.
Why? I still believe in Lanzer the admin. I believe that he's crazy about Gaia still; I don't think he's obsessed about money or anything. If he's helping manage a site with millions and millions of users, though, there's bound to be decisions that are made that don't necessarily benefit the users long-term. It doesn't make Lanzer a bad person.
It seems like nothing really worth buying is out of the cash shop, and it is unfair that newer users can get rich faster than older users by doing what Gaia has always discouraged--pretty much buying gold.
We can all reminisce about a time in which we could spend 14k and buy a chyaku norisu scarf that's now worth almost ten times that. This part of Gaia won't come back. Part of the marketplace inflation is due to Gaia's sheer size. It's the law of demand. I'm sure that millions of users would like a chyaku norisu scarf. The simple fact is that there aren't millions of them. This is enough to drive up the price--to the point where people are paying over 100k just for a simple scarf. This isn't under the admins control, sadly. (The 2% tax that doesn't help inflation at all is, of course...)
I do wish for what can come back to come back, though.
I'll sign.