Welcome to Gaia! ::

Here's some advice, genius:

1. Even fiction has to be 'realistically' BELIEVABLE. Katekyo Hitman Reborn! has people with powers, toddlers that run around and try to kill people, time travel, etc. It still makes ******** sense in its own world. Your story doesn't.

2. Don't copy things from manga

3.Learn to spell

4. Go away and come back when you won't act like a child just because you don't like the responses you get.
Somebody call the Waaahmbulance! wahmbulance

The best proof of concept you have is an extremely rough premise. Comparing it to the idea behind Hitman Reborn!, we can only see that they are remarkably similar. The fact that you flipped the ******** out instead of keeping your head cool shows that you probably lack the maturity to get this done.

When you pitch an idea, expect people to find an example of something that feels similar to your pitch. They will then question what makes yours special. Your job is to convince people that not only is your idea thought out but that you are worth working with to complete it.

You want a Japanese character but you did not do the research to make him believable to anyone who isn't an idiot who squeals with glee at the idea of reading something about someone who is Japanese. You don't bother to spell correctly or use proper grammar. Worst of all, you act like a four-year-old whose parents refused to buy them candy at the supermarket and now you want the world to shut up.

Get the ******** over yourself. You are not a special little snowflake.
Black Whol
ok i know i aked like a baby and im sorry about thati know my spelling sucks and im not useing proper grammer like now.

so list whats wrong with my idea and tell me how i can improve it but pleas say its noy realistic or it dosent any scens cause thats the point of this manga its not about real mafia ganhgs were they sell drugs and and robe banks like i said befor its a gag like in one peic there isnt realy a gumgum fruit and all those stuff.

p.s
im realy realy realy realy realy realy rrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrreeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaaalllllllyyyyyyyyyyyy sorry


How are you supposed to make gags about the mafia if you don't know what the mafia is about. Comedy is about knowing more about the subject than your audience and timing, not about making s**t up.
Black Whol

so list whats wrong with my idea and tell me how i can improve it but pleas say its noy realistic or it dosent any scens cause thats the point of this manga its not about real mafia ganhgs were they sell drugs and and robe banks like i said befor its a gag like in one peic there isnt realy a gumgum fruit and all those stuff.


Jesus. What browser are you using? Upgrade to something with integrated spellheck, because this is just embarrassing.

And they've told you what they think you can do to improve this concept. Namely, come up with something else. Go back and re-read the first few replies. Even if you weren't aware of the similarity between your potential comic and the Shonen Jump comic everyone is mentioning, it's best to concede to the better-known property.
I think the most telling part is where you change the age by a year thinking that neatly sidesteps the age problem.

The main problem is still there, you insufferable moron. Your protagonist's dad has no logical reason to even want to train his son to become a member of the mafia when i'm sure there are plenty of gangbangers and thugs he can choose from.

Your premise is asinine and I sincerely doubt you've got the writing ability to make this in anyway redeemable. Despite what mom and dad say, there is such a thing as a bad idea. Are you really so attached to this idea that you cannot plainly see how ridiculous it is?

And for the love of all things, just get firefox. You need the spellcheck feature.
Black Whol
p.s im acthuly a good writer i just dont thry as much on gaia cause its not realy not that importent


Wrong. A real writer that takes real pride in their work pours thought into every word and sentence that they type. They make sure that they have communicated their idea in the clearest manner possible; they double- and triple-check for embarrassing misspellings and other typos; they re-read three or four times to make sure that every idea flows well and is phrased the best possible way. Everything you type, literally, is representative of you as a writer -- and I mean "literally" there in the traditional sense, instead of as a generic intensifier. If you don't care enough about your writing to make sure that your forum posts are understandable, what the hell good are you?
Now I'm toying with the idea you might just be a clever troll. Why would he trust the son who he barely knows? Just scrap the idea and start over. Is that so goddamn hard? You are not a good writer. you are not even a passable writer. A good writer doesn't need a special occasion to at least attempt to write like someone with a glimmer of intelligence. A good writer could see why your premise is not a good idea if you haven't the comedy writing chops for it (and you most certainly don't). Don't thank me, you still have no clue what the hell you're doing.
Never going to change, eh? Enjoy being a horrible writer forever.

Even if the internet isn't all serious, your spelling, grammar, and overall tone is how you represent yourself to the world. If it types like an idiot, acts like an idiot, and sounds like an idiot, what must it be???

(hint: an idiot)

(hint: that idiot is you)
Enjoy mediocrity forever, then.

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get Items
Get Gaia Cash
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff