Welcome to Gaia! ::

AnarchoPhiliac's avatar

Liberal Genius

DND removes report on killing of Canadian soldier by Israeli forces

Quote:
The Defence Department has quietly removed from the Internet a report into the killing of a Canadian military officer by Israeli forces, a move the soldier’s widow says is linked to the Conservative government’s reluctance to criticize Israel for any wrongdoing.

Maj. Paeta Hess-von Kruedener and three other United Nations observers were killed in 2006 when the Israeli military targeted their small outpost with repeated artillery barrages as well as an attack by a fighter aircraft.

IN early 2008, the Defence Department posted on its website a 67-page report from the Canadian Forces board of inquiry into the killing. The board found Hess-von Kruedener’s death was preventable and caused by the Israeli military.

But less than a year later, the report was quietly removed from the DND website and has since remained off-limits to the public through official channels.

Hess-von Kruedener’s widow, Cynthia, told the Citizen that the decision to remove the document from the public domain was made by DND and the government in an effort to protect Israel’s reputation.

“They don’t want people reading about it,” she said. “It’s embarrassing to the Israelis and, as we know, Prime Minister (Stephen) Harper has given his unconditional support to the Israelis.”

The circumstances surrounding Hess-von Kruedener’s death and the attempts by DND and the Canadian Forces to limit access to the board of inquiry report are outlined in an article in the new edition of Legion magazine, an Ottawa-based publication sent to members of the Royal Canadian Legion.

DND originally refused to provide the magazine with the previously public board of inquiry report, claiming the publication needed to use the access-to-information law to obtain a copy.

Legion magazine obtained a copy of the report by other means. It has now posted the report on its website.

In an email sent to the Citizen, DND confirmed it had removed the board of inquiry report from its website in early 2009 for security reasons “after it was discovered that some of its content is considered protected information.”

That explanation, however, doesn’t stand up to scrutiny as Legion magazine compared both the 2008 version and the 2012 copy issued under the access law, discovering that the latest version actually contains more information than the original.

The Legion article also raises questions about the disappearance from DND of a United Nations report into the killing. The document was used by the Canadian Forces for its board of inquiry and the UN report is cited in the Canadian report. But DND’s access to information branch claims it has done a thorough search of records and no such report could be found.

DND could not comment on claims by defence sources that hard copies of the board of inquiry report were also removed from military libraries.

The death of Hess-von Kruedener, a UN observer assigned to the Israeli-Lebanon border, has largely been forgotten.

The Israeli attack on the UN outpost began shortly after noon on July 25, 2006, prompting the UN deputy secretary general to almost immediately call the Israeli ambassador to the UN and complain.

Several hours later another artillery barrage hit the outpost. That was followed by another 16 artillery rounds hitting the base, destroying most of the buildings above ground and blowing the door off the underground bunker where Hess-von Kruedener and his fellow peacekeepers had taken refuge.

At one point, a general in charge of UN operations in Lebanon called the Israeli liaison officer and told him, “You’re killing my people.” Previously, the Israelis halted such attacks when protests were received.

Later that day, an Israeli fighter pilot directed a precision-guided bomb through the door of the UN bunker. The blast from the massive bomb killed the four men.

Gen. Rick Hillier, then the chief of the defence staff, later described the major’s death as a “tragic accident.”

Cynthia Hess-von Kruedener told the Citizen that the Canadian Forces didn’t inform her of her husband’s death. Instead, she learned he had been killed from a television news report.

The Legion article notes the Israelis had deliberately targeted the base. The base had been included in the Israeli military’s “targeting list” which they acknowledged was an error on their part.

Cynthia Hess-von Kruedener also takes issue with some of the remarks made by Harper about her husband. At the time of the killing, Harper questioned what Hess-von Kruedener was doing at the UN outpost.

She said the answer is simple: He was doing his job as ordered by the Canadian Forces and government of Canada. “Instead of asking why this happened, (Harper) turned it onto an innocent UN peacekeeper,” she said.

On Sept. 19, 2006, then-Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert wrote Harper, expressing his deep regret. Harper wrote back on Nov. 20, 2006, thanking Olmert for his “expression of condolences, for the Israeli government’s rapid investigation of the incident and for information provided to Canadian officials.”

However, the Legion magazine article noted that the Israelis refused to answer questions from Canada about the attack.


tl;dr: The Department of National Defense removes this report documenting the death of a Canadian soldier killed by the IDF from the public domain.

You would think that it's about winning the Jewish vote, but there are only two ridings where that vote really matters: Thornhill and Mt. Royal, and the latter has been ardently Liberal for decades. Essentially, the whole notion of remaining so ardently pro-Israel for the purpose of retaining 1 seat from the +150 that they currently have under their belt makes little sense.

The reason behind this is strange. Stephen Harper has staked himself out as an unabashed supporter of Israel, as has his entire caucus and cabinet, to the point that in the realm of foreign policy, not only are we no longer stand for Canada, but arguably we hold no clout with Israel.

To any Canadian reading this, listen up: basically your Conservative MPs are more beholden to a foreign state than they are to your constituency or your country.

This makes me furious.
Disa Uniflora's avatar

Perfect Hunter

9,450 Points
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Jolly Roger 50
  • Brandisher 100
******** c**t.
The Danguy's avatar

Tipsy Explorer

Careful Anarcho, some ******** in the pay of AIPAC or the IDF is bound to come along and call you an anti-semite for daring to bring this up.
Wendigo's avatar

Manly Explorer

8,750 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Super Tipsy 200
Reminds me of that Pat Tillman thing, except nobody set out t' lionize him for his heroic charge into enemy fire that wasn't there, they just want to erase him.

Man, though, guy's history. Congo and that. Wonder why he was still out doing it.
........what the frick.
Camera Stellata 's avatar

7,400 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Citizen 200
  • Full closet 200
If support for Israel is out of principle I'd love to know what the principle is.
The Danguy's avatar

Tipsy Explorer

Camera Stellata
If support for Israel is out of principle I'd love to know what the principle is.
The principle of holy dog s**t you anti-semite how dare you question Israel?
washu_2004's avatar

Shameless Heckler

10,450 Points
  • Brandisher 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Peoplewatcher 100
The Danguy
Careful Anarcho, some ******** in the pay of AIPAC or the IDF is bound to come along and call you an anti-semite for daring to bring this up.


Or some 'useful idiot' or paid PR spin doctor from the PLO will try and preempt this and end up looking very stupid.
Wendigo's avatar

Manly Explorer

8,750 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Super Tipsy 200
washu_2004
The Danguy
Careful Anarcho, some ******** in the pay of AIPAC or the IDF is bound to come along and call you an anti-semite for daring to bring this up.


Or some 'useful idiot' or paid PR spin doctor from the PLO will try and preempt this and end up looking very stupid.
How do you figure useful idiocy applies? Did the PLO try to suppress Major Paeta Derek Hess-von Kruedener's death to make it look like Israel tried to suppress his death to make it look as though Israeli airstrikes targeting friendly positions didn't happen, in order that they might frame Israel for propagandizing its own mixed record in these conflicts?

I mean, Harper is pretty useful, but the PLO's not been involved heretofore, so far as I know. The Lebanon war in 2006 wasn't even against the PLO, it was against Hezbollah.
Wendigo
washu_2004
The Danguy
Careful Anarcho, some ******** in the pay of AIPAC or the IDF is bound to come along and call you an anti-semite for daring to bring this up.


Or some 'useful idiot' or paid PR spin doctor from the PLO will try and preempt this and end up looking very stupid.
How do you figure useful idiocy applies? Did the PLO try to suppress Major Paeta Derek Hess-von Kruedener's death to make it look like Israel tried to suppress his death to make it look as though Israeli airstrikes targeting friendly positions didn't happen, in order that they might frame Israel for propagandizing its own mixed record in these conflicts?

I mean, Harper is pretty useful, but the PLO's not been involved heretofore, so far as I know. The Lebanon war in 2006 wasn't even against the PLO, it was against Hezbollah.

Are the PLO even still active? I mean Hamas already controls Gaza, I can't imagine Fatah's control on the west bank is a whole lot better.

******** scratch that. 2 Seconds on wikipedia has shown that the PLO officially recognises Israel's right to exist in peace and likewise Israel recognises the PLO right to represent the Palestinian people.
Maybe the report wasn't that important?
TANRailgun's avatar

Familiar Smoker

I really don't understand why the US, UK, and Canada have such a massive hard-on for Israel. Really, what the ******** have they done for ANYONE recently other than overreact and kill brown people?


Someone PLEASE, I beg you, explain it to me.
Camera Stellata 's avatar

7,400 Points
  • Dressed Up 200
  • Citizen 200
  • Full closet 200
The Danguy
Camera Stellata
If support for Israel is out of principle I'd love to know what the principle is.
The principle of holy dog s**t you anti-semite how dare you question Israel?
Perhaps, but I'd be surprised if it polarised Canadian opinion the same way it does the US.
Wendigo's avatar

Manly Explorer

8,750 Points
  • Invisibility 100
  • Money Never Sleeps 200
  • Super Tipsy 200
TANRailgun
I really don't understand why the US, UK, and Canada have such a massive hard-on for Israel. Really, what the ******** have they done for ANYONE recently other than overreact and kill brown people?


Someone PLEASE, I beg you, explain it to me.
They make nice handguns.

Also, they help us infect the Iranians with computer viruses that then break loose and provide IT guys with some headaches.
nobounce the 2nd's avatar

Dapper Dabbler

15,300 Points
  • Pie For All! 300
  • Pie Trafficker 100
  • Pie Hoarder by Proxy 150
The Danguy
Camera Stellata
If support for Israel is out of principle I'd love to know what the principle is.
The principle of holy dog s**t you anti-semite how dare you question Israel?


too bad Israel does not equal Jewish, so one could not call someone anti-semitic for being the polices and practices of a sovereign country since that country has a great many religions that exist within its boarders. You can only be an anti-semite if you are against an jewish individual or group of jewish individuals

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games