Anonconda
- Quote
- Report Post
- Posted: Sat, 07 Nov 2009 03:26:51 +0000
Mokie7
AndiConda3
tempestswordsman
Mokie7
I know people are excited about a potential step forward in the gay marriage debate.... but doesn't this seem a lot like "separate but equal" to anyone else?
The solution here is actually quite simple. Take away the government's ability to grant "marriage certificates" and instead let it only be domestic partnerships then marriage itself is only a religious institution.
Agreed, I am pro separation of church and state, and I favor this option over all others. Remove the word marriage from all legal documents and replace with civil union or domestic partnership. Or just give marriage rights to gays, whatever. Both give equality, the former has an added bonus of separating church and state.
you know, I think I support this too.
In my discussions with anti-gay marriage conservatives, I have had much more success using this argument. I find that they are more willing to support a separation of church and state, than to have "the government endorse an 'invalid marriage'." Of course there is no reason a gay marriage should be invalid, but arguing with them over that fact rarely goes anywhere.