Welcome to Gaia! ::

Hello there. Below is a rough draft of a short story that came to me as I drove today. Literally. The words just came to me and I had to put them down. I've not had a chance to edit, to change, and I would like to think that the story as it is, is quite good. Please try to be constructive with any criticisms and even with your praise. I understand it is really quite short. It was meant to be.


The wizened, ancient young man stood there on top of that dune. With a practiced ease he stamped his staff and spoke to the winds of fortune. “Why, if may age is youth, is my name bitterness? Why have I only regret and indecision for companions? What terrifying gentle and careless flap of butterfly wings unleashes this howling storm upon me that leaves me with only this deluge of memories come unbidden?” He wore the dress of the old times; of times when danger, death and violence were near at hand. He dressed as if humanity had not evolved ways to deal with lack of water, of harsh sun and biting wind. As if humanity had not tamed the wild.

Perhaps this was because he lived in some out of the way place, hidden and cut off. Perhaps he was too poor to afford these miracles. And so in the fashion of all humans everywhere, in the fashion of those more civilized, more advanced...cultured they pitied him. What a poor unfortunate! They said. He’d not experienced the amazingness of the thingamajiggy, the elegance of the boodlebeep, the ease of the ginnyhoop. These things that made up their daily lives were alien to him…he was alien to them.

And everywhere he went he left behind these thoughts and one more. It took time but slowly it grew. Surely it wasn’t because…he scorned them? Because they made men soft in the body and head and was making their soul a mushy, awful substance with no worth. Surely not that. No. No. He was to be pitied.

The wind held no answer in its howling, screaming. It just passed over, and around, and through his very bones. Tiredly he took a step.
This isn't exactly constructive criticism but I really love this bit:

TheyCallMeJustiursa
And so in the fashion of all humans everywhere, in the fashion of those more civilized, more advanced...cultured they pitied him. What a poor unfortunate! They said. He’d not experienced the amazingness of the thingamajiggy, the elegance of the boodlebeep, the ease of the ginnyhoop. .
Glitterdrome
This isn't exactly constructive criticism but I really love this bit:

TheyCallMeJustiursa
And so in the fashion of all humans everywhere, in the fashion of those more civilized, more advanced...cultured they pitied him. What a poor unfortunate! They said. He’d not experienced the amazingness of the thingamajiggy, the elegance of the boodlebeep, the ease of the ginnyhoop. .

Oh? Could you possibly explain why? It would help immensely.
TheyCallMeJustiursa
Glitterdrome
This isn't exactly constructive criticism but I really love this bit:

TheyCallMeJustiursa
And so in the fashion of all humans everywhere, in the fashion of those more civilized, more advanced...cultured they pitied him. What a poor unfortunate! They said. He’d not experienced the amazingness of the thingamajiggy, the elegance of the boodlebeep, the ease of the ginnyhoop. .

Oh? Could you possibly explain why? It would help immensely.


I love the use of the ridiculous, over-the-top colloquialisms (thingamajiggy, boodlebeep, ginnyhoop); such a juxtaposition to the rest of the vocabulary used. Because they are nonsensical but accessible words and can be understood in context I think it gives a feel for the "fashion of all humans" you're referring to. Also because the words have no actual meaning it exacerbates the 'otherness' of the central character as even someone growing up knowing a particular language would not know such colloquialisms unless they had spent time communicating regularly with other people.

(sorry, I tend to come across accidentally pretentious when I discuss writing, hope it didn't show too much here 4laugh )
Glitterdrome
TheyCallMeJustiursa
Glitterdrome
This isn't exactly constructive criticism but I really love this bit:

TheyCallMeJustiursa
And so in the fashion of all humans everywhere, in the fashion of those more civilized, more advanced...cultured they pitied him. What a poor unfortunate! They said. He’d not experienced the amazingness of the thingamajiggy, the elegance of the boodlebeep, the ease of the ginnyhoop. .

Oh? Could you possibly explain why? It would help immensely.


I love the use of the ridiculous, over-the-top colloquialisms (thingamajiggy, boodlebeep, ginnyhoop); such a juxtaposition to the rest of the vocabulary used. Because they are nonsensical but accessible words and can be understood in context I think it gives a feel for the "fashion of all humans" you're referring to. Also because the words have no actual meaning it exacerbates the 'otherness' of the central character as even someone growing up knowing a particular language would not know such colloquialisms unless they had spent time communicating regularly with other people.

(sorry, I tend to come across accidentally pretentious when I discuss writing, hope it didn't show too much here 4laugh )

That was quite helpful actually thank you.
Didn't want to keep reading after your first sentence. You contradict yourself straight away. What is an ancient young man?

Skimmed a bit and found more errors and lost interest.
Cogent Dream
Didn't want to keep reading after your first sentence. You contradict yourself straight away. What is an ancient young man?

Skimmed a bit and found more errors and lost interest.

The contradiction is done on purpose. It was done to exaggerate the fact that though he is a young man, he feels old, he acts old. And that he belongs to another time.

The other errors are likely from it being a rough draft that I felt I had to post immediately.

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get Items
Get Gaia Cash
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff