hit vibes
I can honestly not see anything from Bloc Party influenced by U2. And if you say stealing doesn't matter then Coldplay stole from them and made it infinities better than U2 could dream of.
Wait, you really aren't against alt rock, you're really just against U2. Which is funny because they aren't even in my top 10, and if you saw the rest of my list, you'd probably like it. But they influenced many bands, so what the ********?
You can not see anything? Well try hearing. The Edge's guitar sound is in most alt rock bands these days. Even if you can't hear it in Bloc Party, there are other countless bands.
Quote:
I can not trust a guitar sound counting as influence. If you look around at music, there are people using the same guitar sounds without knowing who the other band even is. It's stupid to say that "their guitar sounds like this, and this band's guitar sounded like this afterward, they were definitely a huge influence on this band."
That is the most redundant way of thinking I've ever had the displeasure of interacting with in my life and if it works that way it's practically making every band inspired by every other band in some sort of weird Ouroboros.
I just have to disagree on this one. If anything, try hearing from the bands themselves, on who were their biggest influences. Search for bands that U2 influenced, it's that easy.
Quote:
And I don't think Radiohead stole at all. If they did steal anything it was probably something like a chord they really liked and then they ran with it, which could actually not be seen as stealing unless they had the definite intent to sound like the song they stole it from. I haven't found any songs that sound like theirs though.
Eh, I've seen a lot of comment that said Radiohead stole from Kraftwerk, Aphex Twin, Wolfmother, Neu, DJ Shadow, The Pixies, and many of their other influences. I'll be glad if that isn't true, but I don't care. It doesn't matter if the band copies, it's about making that perfect sound, that mixture of styles, that weres supposedly invented before them.
Quote:
Also what??? The Grammy Awards don't mean anything to me. Me liking an artist doesn't have to make me like the awards their getting or the award shows that they're on. That's a very stupid chain of events. You're the one who brought up the Grammy Awards in the first place by saying U2 has 22
"more than any other artist" and that only makes me believe that Grammy Awards mean something to you.
You're not gonna strike a chord with me if you say a random unknown band with mixed reactions is better than a great band with a big legacy. I usually bring up critics when discussing. And I did, but you said you don't care about the critics. So basically, this only leaves your subjective opinion, which I can't change, but when I leave this thread. I'm still gonna hear way more positives about U2, or any other great bands you diss, than negatives. (well now it's a mixed reaction with that iTunes scandal but whatever)
Quote:
Ultimate Guitar and YouTube forums?? I'm laughing. You act like any forum is more valid than another. That's very untrue, there are going to be people that disagree with you everywhere you go, and calling an entire website weird because two people disagree with you is so close-minded and it will definitely work to your disadvantage because I guess you'll be staying mentally and musically 12 for the rest of your life.
I would agree with you if that was true, but I had a lot of fights here (you wouldn't even rank in my top 100 feuds, simply because of your rare taste), but they usually evolved about a different cause than on UG or YT, that's the point. You bring up some opinions opposite of anything I've heard from a typical user, for example with The Beatles; I don't care if you dislike The Beatles if 95 out of 100 people like them. Same with U2. And that is pretty much the main point of this. You're telling me U2 sucks as if that's something the majority accepts. And now I should try to have a conversation with you; to conclude that hell has frozen over and pigs are flying? You have your opinions but I won't change mine, especially if the majority is with me.
Quote:
And just a follow up statement regarding you saying that influence doesn't really have anything to do with anything, that's precisely what makes a band quality enough for a
best band. If you can't see that then you may need some professional help.
Hope you find it.
And here you suggest I get some professional help because of a subjective argument about a band? Alright, I see the deal. You probably didn't understand what I was trying to say, as English is not my primary language and I remember tripping up there. I was probably saying that kids wearing T-Shirt doesn't have a lot to do with the bands they influenced, and that what you said was going off-topic. That's all. But it's funny that a person that dislikes The Beatles and U2 and has a rare and unconventional taste is suggesting me something.