Lord Kronus
(?)Community Member
- Report Post
- Posted: Tue, 04 Nov 2008 17:45:22 +0000
garra_eyes
dragonmatt5
o i
However many people can be directed to new directions with discussion, so saying you cannot affect another beliefs is foolish. So can respond to logic, so can to fear, but many people can change their beliefs under the right situations.
However many people can be directed to new directions with discussion, so saying you cannot affect another beliefs is foolish. So can respond to logic, so can to fear, but many people can change their beliefs under the right situations.
Not to mention the fact that a belief as huge an as important as religion is likely not going to be made based on one argument or discussion. Granted, there may be one particular argument or discussion that kind of seals the deal and gets a convert to whatever religion, but chances are it's going to take a lot of different experiences to get someone to completely change their views on the origin of the universe, our purpose in life, and all the other big questions addressed by religion (not to mention all the small ones).
Sure, my discussion with an atheist my not give that person a burning desire to become Catholic. I don't expect it to. But I believe the teachings of the Catholic church are true and I believe that there is an ultimate truth out there. My goal is not to make people become Catholic. My goal is to open people up to the possibility of the "truth" presented by the Church. If it really is true and the people I'm talking to really re open to it, then yeah, they will eventually become Catholic. However, if they are open to accepting new things, but what I believe to be truth isn't really truth, they're not going to accept it and no harm done.
My arguments with people are not about what is or is not right or true. They're about what I believe to be right and true and about whether or not the person I'm talking to is even willing to consider my stance or if they plan to just ignore it.
Of course, this is all very idealistic and the difficulty comes when you turn this around.
I'll admit, there are some possibilities I am definately not open to. Maybe that will change with more prodding from individuals with those beliefs. Maybe not. I have no way of knowing. Maybe I believe in my truth simply because I am not open to the ultimate truth. Maybe there is no ultimate truth. I don't really know.
But that's kind of the tragedy of the human condition, isn't it. We can never really be sure of anything. All we can do is try to make sense of the world and try to help others do the same.
well i have to flat out disagree with you.
there is no ultimate purpose in life other than what evry other animal does. also i and most other aithisets don't care at all with what people believe is true, we belive in what is true. and what makes us different than a religious group is when new information becomes available then we will always change our minds if th new information contradicts or proves wrong something we thought was true before.
i am always open to new ideas and new discoveries
all the other questions that religion claims to answer are equally ridiculous and really only exist to attract people to them who are afraid don't know or are just plain stupid.
the reason i argue is because i want truth and not lies and slander that lead to pain suffering of others and slowign down science. all of which religion does.