Welcome to Gaia! ::


Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Well, they're animals; they don;t have the same rights

Why is marriage different, then? Or, perhaps more importantly: why not?

It isn't; just as they don't have the right to do certain things, they don't have the right to marry nor we the right to marry them

Yes, it is. Animal's consent matters for marriage, but not for ownership? Why is that?

Because of the law; The law requires you consent to be married, it does not require a animal consenting to ownership. Moreover, most animals would not be intelligent enough to consent in either situation.

The question of the thread is "should," not "can."
Do you believe animals, therefore, should not be allowed to be owned as pets, for food, or for other means, then, if they cannot consent?

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

It isn't; just as they don't have the right to do certain things, they don't have the right to marry nor we the right to marry them

Yes, it is. Animal's consent matters for marriage, but not for ownership? Why is that?

Because of the law; The law requires you consent to be married, it does not require a animal consenting to ownership. Moreover, most animals would not be intelligent enough to consent in either situation.

The question of the thread is "should," not "can."
Do you believe animals, therefore, should not be allowed to be owned as pets, for food, or for other means, then, if they cannot consent?

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

It isn't; just as they don't have the right to do certain things, they don't have the right to marry nor we the right to marry them

Yes, it is. Animal's consent matters for marriage, but not for ownership? Why is that?

Because of the law; The law requires you consent to be married, it does not require a animal consenting to ownership. Moreover, most animals would not be intelligent enough to consent in either situation.

The question of the thread is "should," not "can."
Do you believe animals, therefore, should not be allowed to be owned as pets, for food, or for other means, then, if they cannot consent?

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Because it's sick and wrong?

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Because of the law; The law requires you consent to be married, it does not require a animal consenting to ownership. Moreover, most animals would not be intelligent enough to consent in either situation.

The question of the thread is "should," not "can."
Do you believe animals, therefore, should not be allowed to be owned as pets, for food, or for other means, then, if they cannot consent?

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Because of the law; The law requires you consent to be married, it does not require a animal consenting to ownership. Moreover, most animals would not be intelligent enough to consent in either situation.

The question of the thread is "should," not "can."
Do you believe animals, therefore, should not be allowed to be owned as pets, for food, or for other means, then, if they cannot consent?

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Yes, they should be allowed as those things. Marriage is a very different thing than any of that.

Yes, it is. It requires less sacrifice from the animal and provides it more freedom. So, I repeat: why those things, but not marriage.

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Because it's sick and wrong?

In what way, and by whose standard? In many respects, marriage would be exactly the same as pet ownership.

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Why should I?

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

I don't know a lot of pet owners who have sex with their pets.

I wasn't aware that marriage was the same thing as sex.
Although, unfortunately, I do know some. stare

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Why should I?

Why wouldn't you?

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Why should I?

Why wouldn't you?

Because I don't have unreasonable expectations for my wife?

Angelic Husband

11,300 Points
  • Millionaire 200
  • Tycoon 200
  • Popular Thread 100
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

Sex is generally an expectation of marriage

Not really. Maybe to a sex-hound.

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Why should I?

Why wouldn't you?

Because I don't have unreasonable expectations for my wife?

I hardly think sex is unreasonable expectation for a married couple.

Quotable Poster

2,300 Points
  • Voter 100
  • Risky Lifestyle 100
  • Hygienic 200
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven
Elus the Stranded
Young King under Heaven

......So, if you got married, you wouldn't expect sex?

Why should I?

Why wouldn't you?

Because I don't have unreasonable expectations for my wife?

I hardly think sex is unreasonable expectation for a married couple.

Sure it is. Why should sex be an obligation?
stealthmongoose


Furthermore, on your note about the spiders; We don't typically rights of sentient personhood to things that don't have the complex neural network necessary for self-awareness or identity.

It's kind of why fetuses aren't considered citizens, among other things.



http://discovermagazine.com/2007/jan/cockroach-consciousness-neuron-similarity
Most people say, 'For heaven's sake, a bug isn't conscious.' But how do we know? We're not sure anymore. I don't kill bugs needlessly anymore."


Tiny Brains =/= Less Complex Brains.

We tend to be biased, as humans with our primate-based intellect. I assure you, that does not make our perceptions any better or more valid than any other non-human animal. It certainly does not guarantee our survival as a species, either.

http://www.utilitarian-essays.com/insect-pain.html

We (the general populace) don't tend to acknowledge that non-human animals are sentient, because then that would just make us look and feel bad.

It is a fallacy to compare a fetus to a fully fledged adult of the same or another species, especially <20wks.

Also, it is legal to have sex with animals in Denmark, as long as you don't abuse them. Animal sex tourism is becoming a thing there. And killing baby giraffes to piss everyone off.

User Image - Blocked by "Display Image" Settings. Click to show.

Do I think you should be allowed to get legal benefits from marrying an animal? Hellll nooo. If that were the case, I would totally marry a spider! Marriages are stupid anyways.

Quick Reply

Submit
Manage Your Items
Other Stuff
Get GCash
Offers
Get Items
More Items
Where Everyone Hangs Out
Other Community Areas
Virtual Spaces
Fun Stuff
Gaia's Games
Mini-Games
Play with GCash
Play with Platinum