So, for me, I grew up reading The Hobbit as a young (young!) child and even saw a live play of it at the Civic Theatre (which was the best play I've ever seen, just so you know).
Following that, I then read The Lord of the Rings (yes, well.... I was never going to be a "normal" child). Then, years later came the news that it would be adapted into a movie. I was absolutely ecstatic!! While people were going on about Harry Potter this, Harry Potter that, I was arguing the point that the story for LOTR was much better and the plot had a lot more meaning to it. I saw the movie on its release day and so forth. So yes, I am one of those "old" fans.
For me, I seem to like The Hobbit better though, probably because I have more memories connected with it and I read it so, so much.
What does everyone else like better, why, and what other Tokien books have you read? (I also have The Silmarillion and The Legend of Sigurd and GudrĂșn.)
I just love how Tolkien took influence from Norse mythology like I have for my stories. =3