Which character do you feel most sorry for?

Do you think Arwen made the right choice?

Yes	86.1%	[ 173 ]
No	13.9%	[ 28 ]
Total Votes:			[ 201 ]

[shneyhey]

Smeagol/ Gollum. I was hoping he would finally change back to being good after helping Frodo. But I guess not. He got what he wanted in the end and died in the process which is tragic

[lublinofpoland]

lurtz, he didn't deserve to die like that cry

[Lisa of 3pn]

Faramir. Because he wasn't the favourite son of Denethor, so he treated him with few respect and showing him that Boromir was better. I was really sad when he had to reconquer Osgiliath. He also helped Frodo.

[Xx-EMK-xX]

I feel sorry for Smeagol-Gollum,the Ring had took his mind just like it did with Frodo crying

[XxEAT ME UP BITCHxX]

ello

[TotchiSnagglepuss5]

Rinnalaiss

xD

If we're including the Sil, then mine's Turin. Pretty much a no-brainer.

Aside from that...yeah, pretty much everyone from the Sil. gonk

Pretty much everyone in The Silmarillion, especially those who fought in The Battle of Unnumbered Tears.
Although, I always felt terrible for Boromir. Everyone hates him, or seems to, and he was taken by the Ring so quickly. It's been awhile since I read the books, but if memory serves, he wasn't quite as much of an a** as movie Boromir. Either way, poor man.

[KiwiNemesis]

Sam!
For God's sake, he should have been more famous than Frodo - he did everything for Frodo. Yeah, he was carrying the ring, but he rescued him from a killer spider, he cheered him up every step of the way, he got replaced by Frodo with Gollum, and still, he carried that lazy-a** up Mount Doom! Geez, Sam, you deserve all the credit <3

[-WitchsWolf-]

Elrond

[Cosmopolitian_101]

Definitely Elrond, for all the reasons you mentioned. It just seems that he loses almost everyone dear to him. Especially that his brother Elros chose mortality while he chose Firstborn, and he has to relive that situation, except with his daughter. Don't forget, he also lost Gil-Galad during the Last Alliance. Also, the entire story of Estel. Elrond opened his heart to a mortal boy who would eventually die, and that mortal boy ended up taking away his daughter as well. I can't blame Aragorn for being in love, but it is still unfortunate for Elrond. And now he has to explain to Celebrian why she won't be seeing her only daughter ever again.

[Aria Asha]

Sam because he lost his best friend in the end, but Frodo left him in good hands. heart

[Agent Mordacai]

Fro-toe. For he was damaged goods by the end.

[Robotic Jehuty]

Gandalf!!! because he had to carry the weight of the world on his shoulders! but then again he wasn't damaged goods like frodo was by the end.. hmm FRODO

[Ayniu]

I feel pretty dang sorry for Turin. And Beleg. Not sure why, but their story (particularly Turin's) really got to me. ;__;

[Blub Coco]

I feel sorry for Gollum, the ring drove him mad. And to Sam, Faramir, Frodo and Bilbo. Made me teary eyed.