knightofthe21stcentury
Eol the Dark Elf
I really like the fox because it seems like one of the only solid connection to "The Hobbit," style-wise. Yes, Bilbo, Gandalf, Gloin, and the ring are in both, but the style changes drastically even for them. I hardly recognized Gandalf as the same guy! "The Hobbit" was filled with more out-and-out magical things like the fox (talking animals, talking wallets, human-animal transformation...), whereas in LotR magic was much more subtle.
I'm not saying either style is better, but it does make "The Hobbit" and "The Lord of the Rings" seem like they take place in two entirely different worlds. That's why I think things like the fox and Tom Bombadil are in the beginning of the first book but seem to disappear after that: to ease the reader's transition between these worlds.
Was he in The Hobbit as well? (Long time since I read).
I meant "like the fox" as in "similar to the fox," the things in the Hobbit were very much like the fox, not that he was actually in the Hobbit. Sorry, I didn't even notice the clarity issue in what I wrote until I re-read it a billion times. Until now I just thought, "What are those guys talking about? I didn't say that."