This was a really hard one. People say Frodo is a weakling, but the rings power was irresistible. Without Sam, Frodo wouldn't of made it, and vice-versa. They depend on each other for survival. And who doesn't love Merry and Pippin? Their mischievousness and humor add so much to the Fellowship. Aragon is a true leader and they would have gotten very far without him. This goes for Legolas as well. Gimli and Legolas contributed a lot of the defending part of the fellowship. Without Gandalf, nothing would've even happened! He's like the father figure everyone feels safe with. Boromir...not going to lie, I hated him at first. But you end up warming up to him and his death is the saddest thing. I voted for Legolas, not because OEMGEE he's hawtt, but because his cheerfulness and great archery skills made me always be rooting for him or interested in what he was doing. Such a hard choice though!!