THREAD CLOSED: Dumbledore's Army has been moved.

[Farren Gold]

AerthBlade

ive always believed that opposites attract.

Opposites attract? Maybe in an alternate universe! But hey that's my opinion and you have yours.

[Riddle Me This Batman]

Like they said oppisites attract, I like DracoxHarry.=D ...Ialso dispise Dumbles.

[Farren Gold]

Molto Alesato

Like they said oppisites attract, I like DracoxHarry.=D ...Ialso dispise Dumbles.

Forget the DracoxHarry, but EXCUSE ME??? You despise DUMBLEDORE? Don't you know that if it hadn't been for him, Harry would have died a long time ago?

[xxradiA C T I O N]

calm down vamp. I love dumbledore too, but shes entitled to her opinion.
I like HarryDraco too, but I hate those stories that make him too girly. Hes supposed to be snotty and aragant just the way I like him<3

[Riddle Me This Batman]

Well Dumbles is just a super manipulative b*****d.

[xxradiA C T I O N]

how so?

[Farren Gold]

AerthBlade

calm down vamp. I love dumbledore too, but shes entitled to her opinion.
I like HarryDraco too, but I hate those stories that make him too girly. Hes supposed to be snotty and aragant just the way I like him<3

No I will NOT calm down! This...person(don't know if you're a dude or a chick) is dissing one of the coolest teachers in the history of literature! I am entitled to my opinion too, and Dumbledore is not a b*****d!

[Farren Gold]

AerthBlade

how so?

Yeah, how so, Molto? ~under breath~And after I welcomed you all nicely.

[The Robotic Kiss]

I always liked the Harry&Hermione pairing. But my hopes were crushed in the 7th book.

I finished rereading the 5th book today. I feel depressed again, the old pain came back when I read the part where my precious Sirius Black died.
WHY J.K. ROWLING, WHY!?
; _____ ;

[Riddle Me This Batman]

*Sigh* This'll take awhile. Lets start when Harry's a baby. Dumbles convinced Lily and James to go into hideing under the Fidelus Charm, a charm that reiles on trust to be effective. Why didn't he just send the Potters, and Longbottems to their ansestrial home, like how Malfoy's have Malfoy Manor. Since they were created long ago they must have had enough protection, more than Godric's hollo.(Which don't forget was a cottage) Lily and James got killed.

Hagrid then meets Sirius at the wreakage. Sirius currently has baby Potter, by Dumbles orders Hagrid brings Harry to the Dursleys while Sirius goes after Peter. After they all met at privte Drive. After completely ignoring Minerva, he drops a ONE year old on a DOOR step in OCTOBER, with no protection. Then leaves for ten years, of course the Dursley's most likely think that someone is watching them so they don't send him to an orphanage. He, by dropping Harry on the Dursley's door step made it so the Dursley's had not choice but to take him in. (Not even asking about the Dursley's opinion, if they wanted Harry or not.) In the sense of blood wards. Most likely to make sure Harry was alive for future manipulations, he placed charms to moneter his heath. (Probably his office trinkets) They would have shown his less than pleasent childhood, such as lack of food, rest and such. There is more than that but let's skip ten years.

Give me a couple minute break.

[Farren Gold]

The Robotic Kiss

I always liked the Harry&Hermione pairing. But my hopes were crushed in the 7th book.

I finished rereading the 5th book today. I feel depressed again, the old pain came back when I read the part where my precious Sirius Black died.
WHY J.K. ROWLING, WHY!?
; _____ ;

I know how you feel. I kinda pretended Sirius was my dad because my dad wasn't around when I was a kid. He's the ideal father figure, right? So when he died, I cried nonstop for a week and I still cry when I see Gary Oldman die in the movie.

[The Robotic Kiss]

VampQueen777

The Robotic Kiss

I always liked the Harry&Hermione pairing. But my hopes were crushed in the 7th book.

I finished rereading the 5th book today. I feel depressed again, the old pain came back when I read the part where my precious Sirius Black died.
WHY J.K. ROWLING, WHY!?
; _____ ;

I know how you feel. I kinda pretended Sirius was my dad because my dad wasn't around when I was a kid. He's the ideal father figure, right? So when he died, I cried nonstop for a week and I still cry when I see Gary Oldman die in the movie.

Aw, I'm sorry. =(
I freaking love Sirius, it just pissed me off when he died! I was like, "UGHH NO, HE'S ******** ALIVE! I DON'T CARE WHAT YOU SAY ROWLING!"

[insert tons of angry rambling here]

But, I slowly had to accept the fact that he wasn't coming back.
T __ T

(Gary Oldman, yum. <3)

[Ariana Dumbledore]

VampQueen777

AerthBlade

calm down vamp. I love dumbledore too, but shes entitled to her opinion.
I like HarryDraco too, but I hate those stories that make him too girly. Hes supposed to be snotty and aragant just the way I like him<3

No I will NOT calm down! This...person(don't know if you're a dude or a chick) is dissing one of the coolest teachers in the history of literature! I am entitled to my opinion too, and Dumbledore is not a b*****d!

You're entitled to an opinion. You're entitled to a right to share your opinion.
You are not entitled to force your opinion on others and get pissed off just because someone disagrees.
:/

My brother was far from perfect. If he truly had wanted Harry save and protected and, you know, healthy, he wouldn't have placed them with the Dursleys.
Hogwarts was supposed to be the most secure place, and he was the one that your Dark Lord feared. He could have kept the boy there, young or not.
The Dursleys were abusive, and just because J.K. mostly brushes over that fact, since she was writting for children in the beginning, when it was mostly happening, doesn't make it not true.
Go read the second book, just the beginning.
Just the part with the Dursleys.
See if you catch the part where Petunia tried to hit Harry in the head with an iron skillet.


@Kiss - He's not dead!
He's on vacation.
In Narnia.

[Farren Gold]

Molto Alesato

*Sigh* This'll take awhile. Lets start when Harry's a baby. Dumbles convinced Lily and James to go into hideing under the Fidelus Charm, a charm that reiles on trust to be effective. Why didn't he just send the Potters, and Longbottems to their ansestrial home, like how Malfoy's have Malfoy Manor. Since they were created long ago they must have had enough protection, more than Godric's hollo.(Which don't forget was a cottage) Lily and James got killed.

Hagrid then meets Sirius at the wreakage. Sirius currently has baby Potter, by Dumbles orders Hagrid brings Harry to the Dursleys while Sirius goes after Peter. After they all met at privte Drive. After completely ignoring Minerva, he drops a ONE year old on a DOOR step in OCTOBER, with no protection. Then leaves for ten years, of course the Dursley's most likely think that someone is watching them so they don't send him to an orphanage. He, by dropping Harry on the Dursley's door step made it so the Dursley's had not choice but to take him in. (Not even asking about the Dursley's opinion, if they wanted Harry or not.) In the sense of blood wards. Most likely to make sure Harry was alive for future manipulations, he placed charms to moneter his heath. (Probably his office trinkets) They would have shown his less than pleasent childhood, such as lack of food, rest and such. There is more than that but let's skip ten years.

Give me a couple minute break.

You know what? The Potters were pursued, not the Longbottoms. Neville was born the day before Harry, making Harry the first in line for the prophecy. Dumbledore didn't know that Lily and James would put their trust in the wrong person. There's nowhere in the book saying that the Potters had an ancestrial home, therefore making Godric's Hollow the safest place.
Sirius willingly gave Harry to Hagrid because he TRUSTED Dumbledore, not because Dumbledore was manipulative. Harry would have been completely safe on the doorstep because the ward his mother placed on him protected Harry. Dumbledore knew that it was better that Harry be raised by Muggles because if he'd dropped him on ,say, the Weasley's doorstep, he'd have been spoiled rotten just because he was famous. Would you rather have had a spoiled prat like Draco be the hero? Dumbledore knew that if Lily's only living relative(Aunt Petunia) lived in the same house as Harry, there was a better chance of him being protected by the charm.
Top that, Molto. biggrin