Welcome to Gaia! :: Hogwarts Houses and Myers-Briggs Personality Types | Forum

Register FaceBook Login Login

 

 
GST

Welcome to Gaia's forums, where millions of members gather to discuss random stuff, make new friends,
complain about life, argue about nothing, laugh at dumb pictures, discuss serious issues and/or curse like sailors.

Lurking is creepy. Quit skulking in the shadows and join the conversation!

Register to reply

Advertisement

Does your Hogwarts House match up to your Myers-Briggs personality type as defined in this post? (read the post! >:o)

Yes 0.52941176470588 52.9% [ 36 ]
No 0.19117647058824 19.1% [ 13 ]
Myers-What? 0.16176470588235 16.2% [ 11 ]
Pollwhore! 0.11764705882353 11.8% [ 8 ]
Total Votes: 68
Tags: hogwarts  houses  myersbriggs  personality  types 
Share:  
forum:93, topic:45420547
1 2 3 >
Since Houses are basically the results of a personality test, I'm curious how they match up with the most accurate* personality test out there: the Myers-Briggs personality test. There are 12 different Myers-Briggs personality types, so ideally there would be 4 for each house. But... I can't decide which four work for each house.

According to this site, the types can be classified into four groups: Protectors, Creators, Intellectuals, and Visionaries.

Protectors (ESTJ, ESFJ, ISTJ, ISFJ):
SJs are observant, stable and motivated by a need to maintain security. They are realistic, routinized administrators requiring tasks be completed correctly and that people behave appropriately. SJs make thorough examinations to ensure everything is done according to plan. They make sure no more and no less credit is given than due. When a need arises, they are quick to provide a solution, provided that the need is justified. SJs are not driven by impulse, but rather by concrete fact. By virtue of their reliable, diligent, industrious, persevering nature, they make excellent leaders.


Creators (ESTP, ESFP, ISTP, ISFP):
SPs are observant, experiential and primarily driven by sensation. They are flexible, aesthetically-aware, "here and now" people that, with hardly a moment's notice, will go where their senses lead. SPs naturally make an effort (with a realistic approach) not to miss an opportunity that may prove to be thrilling, pleasing or otherwise valuable. SPs are are laid back, open-minded and love to feel alive. They have a tendency toward athletics and anything that involves creating or crafting.


Intellectuals (ENTJ, ENTP, INTJ, INTP):
NTs are introspective, logical and on a constant quest for knowledge. They are practical and unsentimental in their approach to problem solving. The actions of an NT are precise and follow a systematic course. Abstract, theoretical and technically adept, NTs are naturally inventive. They can also be described as being analytical, intellectual, inquisitive, independent and complex.


Visionaries (ENFJ, ENFP, INFJ, INFP):
NFs are introspective, intuitive and highly idealistic. They are subjective, compassionate "feeler" people that desire to contribute goodness and meaning to the lives of others. They are effective at doing this through their nurturing, insightful and encouraging nature. NFs despise conflict. They will do everything they can to make sure their loved ones get along with each other and are happy. NFs are imaginitive, creatively inclined and passionate about their choice causes.



As you can see, my best guess is that Gryffindor = Protectors, Slytherin = Creators, Ravenclaw = Intellectuals, and Hufflepuff = Visionaries. I think Ravenclaw matches up the best and Gryffindor the worst. So...

What is your house and your personality type (don't know your type? click here)? Does it match up to the comparison I put here? What do you think? surprised


*in my opinion
 
     
http://i50.tinypic.com/20jfghs.png
Thanks to Victorian Prostetute for the av art! biggrin
 
ISFP

Slytherin

Wewt-eth
     
It's elementary, my dear Watson.
INTP. Ravenclaw?
works for me.
 
     
Has anyone claimed the position as Aburame Torune's Fanwhore of A/M/C?

If not, I call it.
Damn you Aburame Clan, with your sexy bug boys.
 
http://badges.mypersonality.info/badge/0/11/116318.png

Protector...

Gryffindor...

yep... smile
     
[link=http://www.tickerclub.com/][image noborder]http://www.tickerclub.com/cache/de33a8a298.png[/image][/link]
Kristinamjs
ID#: 9921946
Intellectual, Ravenclaw, as I expected.
 
     
http://feltbeats.com/forum/gallery/30_03_09_08_3_33_49.jpg

heart Draco Malfoy/Tom Felton Lovers heart :
57!

heart Team Taylor! heart


WARNING - Thread killer.
 
INTP Intellectual. Yup, Ravenclaw. =)
     
Yeah, I could see myself as a Slytherin
 
     
 
ISTP - The "Craftsman"

Slytherin

Yup. mrgreen
     
"Us two shall glide in hand in hand,
Our assaulted hearts undone.
The holes shall bleed in perfect sync,
Us two shall then be one."

~ Miss_Smarticle
INFP

Hufflepuff. heart
 
     
 
intj. Sounds right. I do belong to ravenclaw.
     

I recently Fractured my ankle I won't be online as much. I miss thee fellow Harry Potter goers. =D


I'mma gunna take over teh Hogwarts..
Miniature disasters and minor catastrophes bring me to my knees.

I actually got ESFP (Entertainer), which is Slytherin.

And I'm normally sorted to Ravenclaw.

But it's interesting that I got Entertainer when I'm a theatre major. xD

Well I must be my own master or a miniature disaster will be the death of me.
 
     
 
Interesting, although personally I think you got Slytherin and Gryffindor mixed up. Sure, if you look at the lables it seems clear, Protectors=Gryffindor, Creators=Slytherin. But if you read the whole thing, I think it's very much the other way around.

Another thing I would like to point out: aren't the houses similar to high school cliques?

Gryffindor = Jocks
Slytherin = Rich Kids
Hufflepuff = Preps
Ravenclaw = Nerds (and proud!)
     


Im a ravenclaw but by your standards i should be a hufflepuff, and i would never, EVER, be in hufflepuff.
 
     
 
I Am The Snorkack
Interesting, although personally I think you got Slytherin and Gryffindor mixed up. Sure, if you look at the lables it seems clear, Protectors=Gryffindor, Creators=Slytherin. But if you read the whole thing, I think it's very much the other way around.

Another thing I would like to point out: aren't the houses similar to high school cliques?

Gryffindor = Jocks
Slytherin = Rich Kids
Hufflepuff = Preps
Ravenclaw = Nerds (and proud!)


I think you need to just fill the preps into gryffindor and slytherin because thats basically what they are jocks and rich kids. and replace it with all the average under acheivers and visual arts kids.
     


"If there's one thing you don't want to die from, it's salmonella. Because if you do, what are you going to do when you get up to the pearly gates? St Peter: "And how did you die?" You: "I had a salad with chicken."..."
INTP Ravenclaw woot
I agree with the above
 
     

Total Value: 371,230 Gold
[Item Information]
1 2 3 >

Quick Reply

Enter both words below, separated by a space:

Can't read the text? Click here

Submit

We will be phasing out support for your browser soon.

Please upgrade to one of these more modern browsers.