Harry Potter Vs. Percy Jackson And The Olympians

Which series do you prefer?

Harry Potter	79.0%	[ 241 ]
Percy Jackson and the Olympians	21.0%	[ 64 ]
Total Votes:			[ 305 ]

[Smooth_Criminal19]

Harry Potter is the one. The movies were awesome and so were the books. I didn't really get into the Lightning Thief all that much as Harry Potter. GO SNAPE!!

[Javier Cross]

Where's the ACTUAL EFFORTS to debate a match, properly when we need one, here? gonk

[Lady Artemis of the Night]

I personally heart both, but I have to say that Harry Potter's just slightly better. Maybe it's because it's been out longer, but my opinion is that PJ is merely a fad. Not that I don't like it! Don't get me wrong. It's just that the next generation will probably be reading Harry Potter like we're reading classics like Shakespeare and not PJ, although if it's during history, who knows? Still, I gotta admit; Rick Riordon's a damn good author.

[Javier Cross]

And so, the plummitting of debating quality begins anew. ;_;

[Vir_Tellum]

I like both honestly, with HP edging out Percy. I just downloaded this new book call The Knights of Galaria on my Kindle. I think I like that better than Percy Jackson as well, but the series is brand new so we'll see.

[Javier Cross]

@Mage Luna

Where can we start in getting the debating quality in this thread to start skyrocketing, already?

[Ultra danielle23]

I like Harry Potter and the Wizard Walks biggrin

[TheQuidditchQueen]

Both are amazing, but....

I HAVE to go with Harry Potter. Potterhead forever!

[EbonyDemon]

HARRY POTTERRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!!!! heart heart heart

[Kurokashi-san]

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

[Javier Cross]

Kurokashi-san

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This is a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

Don't forget about social matters and Military War-waging capabilities both sides in here can offer, as well.
Methinks we have begun to seriously lack out in this matter, and that things must change for the better if this thread wants to stay alive rather than be a thread of lacklustre responses and wimptacular results, actually.

[Kurokashi-san]

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This is a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

Don't forget about social matters and Military War-waging capabilities both sides in here can offer, as well.
Methinks we have begun to seriously lack out in this matter, and that things must change for the better if this thread wants to stay alive rather than be a thread of lacklustre responses and wimptacular results, actually.

From what little I know of Percy Jackson there is a comparison on the most basic level to Harry Potter. Both deal with young boys discovering secrets of their parents that drag them into a world beyond human understanding.

[Javier Cross]

Kurokashi-san

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This is a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

Don't forget about social matters and Military War-waging capabilities both sides in here can offer, as well.
Methinks we have begun to seriously lack out in this matter, and that things must change for the better if this thread wants to stay alive rather than be a thread of lacklustre responses and wimptacular results, actually.

From what little I know of Percy Jackson there is a comparison on the most basic level to Harry Potter. Both deal with young boys discovering secrets of their parents that drag them into a world beyond human understanding.

You take to account the times of the Round Table, and its actually Older than Feudalism, in fact, but unfortunately we got too many illiterate cases on this thread to take notice of it and then comment and nod on the idea, while also expanding on the matter, altogether.
You're forgetting about the Legacy of Susan Cooper's The Dark Is Rising series, which Camp Half-Blood is more or less to that series what the Wheel of Time series(by the late Robert Jordan) is to Middle-Earth, itself, in fact.

Also, Camp Half-Blood has Greek Firebombs according to the Byzantine Imperial Legends from the Middle Ages, which will get worse when someone tries to use water to put them out, and the flames are Green!
They also have Guns and already clearly know how to use said Guns, to begin with, so it stands to reason even the Mere Human Mercs(if enhanced enough to see abnormalities) would know how to get their artillery into position to where enemy forces await(which is why the Potter-world MUST rely on Combined Species Warfare to pull themselves out!)

[Kurokashi-san]

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This is a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

Don't forget about social matters and Military War-waging capabilities both sides in here can offer, as well.
Methinks we have begun to seriously lack out in this matter, and that things must change for the better if this thread wants to stay alive rather than be a thread of lacklustre responses and wimptacular results, actually.

From what little I know of Percy Jackson there is a comparison on the most basic level to Harry Potter. Both deal with young boys discovering secrets of their parents that drag them into a world beyond human understanding.

You take to account the times of the Round Table, and its actually Older than Feudalism, in fact, but unfortunately we got too many illiterate cases on this thread to take notice of it and then comment and nod on the idea, while also expanding on the matter, altogether.
You're forgetting about the Legacy of Susan Cooper's The Dark Is Rising series, which Camp Half-Blood is more or less to that series what the Wheel of Time series(by the late Robert Jordan) is to Middle-Earth, itself, in fact.

Also, Camp Half-Blood has Greek Firebombs according to the Byzantine Imperial Legends from the Middle Ages, which will get worse when someone tries to use water to put them out, and the flames are Green!
They also have Guns and already clearly know how to use said Guns, to begin with, so it stands to reason even the Mere Human Mercs(if enhanced enough to see abnormalities) would know how to get their artillery into position to where enemy forces await(which is why the Potter-world MUST rely on Combined Species Warfare to pull themselves out!)

I agree with your point on this matter.

[Javier Cross]

Kurokashi-san

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

Javier Cross

Kurokashi-san

I have not read Percy Jackson, but this thread leaves me with a question. Where is the actual debate? This is a popularity contest when it should be a contrast in story-telling style, character development, and story content.

Don't forget about social matters and Military War-waging capabilities both sides in here can offer, as well.
Methinks we have begun to seriously lack out in this matter, and that things must change for the better if this thread wants to stay alive rather than be a thread of lacklustre responses and wimptacular results, actually.

From what little I know of Percy Jackson there is a comparison on the most basic level to Harry Potter. Both deal with young boys discovering secrets of their parents that drag them into a world beyond human understanding.

You take to account the times of the Round Table, and its actually Older than Feudalism, in fact, but unfortunately we got too many illiterate cases on this thread to take notice of it and then comment and nod on the idea, while also expanding on the matter, altogether.
You're forgetting about the Legacy of Susan Cooper's The Dark Is Rising series, which Camp Half-Blood is more or less to that series what the Wheel of Time series(by the late Robert Jordan) is to Middle-Earth, itself, in fact.

Also, Camp Half-Blood has Greek Firebombs according to the Byzantine Imperial Legends from the Middle Ages, which will get worse when someone tries to use water to put them out, and the flames are Green!
They also have Guns and already clearly know how to use said Guns, to begin with, so it stands to reason even the Mere Human Mercs(if enhanced enough to see abnormalities) would know how to get their artillery into position to where enemy forces await(which is why the Potter-world MUST rely on Combined Species Warfare to pull themselves out!)

I agree with your point on this matter.

Meantime, I uncovered more viable uses for Veelas in war situations APART from attracting Aphy's bloodlines, themselves, and diverting their attention even though they cannot kill them outright or get their species to suffer mass heartbreaks to commit mass suicides.
Did you know their true forms allow them to unleash Brutal Elemental Storms and allows them to unleash infernos from their hands?
I could go and fetch the link about Veela abilities in their True Forms, if you like, actually.

If the Potter-world wants to play it smart, they MUST rely on Combined Species Warfare and play it smart, a lot of their Human forces are already far behind as to how to wage war in a coherent manner, these days, and they gotta be caught up by now if they want to stay alive!