This guild is kind of a treasure, to me. I'm in a few roleplaying guilds, and I appreciate all of them for different reasons. This one has spawned a few of the shorter (but literate) roleplays that I have REALLY found to be interesting and enjoyable. I lurk a lot here, when I've grown completely disgusted with Barton Town's lack of originality and literacy (or the occasional over-literacy). This guild is a great resource for anyone looking outside of the main slew. Instead of spending hours on Barton Town looking for roleplays that aren't full of one-liners, it usually only takes a few seconds to check here and see if there's anything good. That's really helpful to me in particular, because I'm really picky about roleplays and I really WILL spend hours in Barton Town because none of the roleplays at the moment are literate, or if they are they're about 20 pages in, or they're full, or they require you to do inordinate amounts of reading of backstory/character interrelationships, and even math or geography to figure out what the heck is going on in the roleplay before you even roleplay! This is a great way to escape all of that for a bit.
As compared to other guilds... This place is pretty decent. I believe it requires a sample? Which in some ways is good, because it weeds out the people who just aren't ready. I'm also a member of The School of Dedicated Roleplayers though, and I think that they've got a decent idea with the 'school' bit. Teaching people how to improve is always good. However, for their purposes, this guild does a good job of keeping the people who will bring down the literacy and enjoyment of the thread out. This is certainly much better than a lot of the genre guilds I've seen, like the 'naruto roleplaying guild' or something. Usually it's disorganized, out of control, and only survives because they have people who are so dedicated to the genre that they don't want to let go of whatever one-liner roleplays they're in, or if they FIND a decent roleplay, who would WANT to give that up? But yes, this guild has seemed to strike a good balance between these things, and fulfills its niche pretty well, I think.
I think it's clear that my experience has been pretty good. I like it here a lot. I really haven't kept track of how long I've been here, but it's been a while. This is just the perspective from someone who checks here often, and really likes what she sees!
smile
*long-winded post over*