I've been collecting data for a while now, and here's what I've got:
From "Home": Aquarium Cuttlefish, Aquarium Goldfish, 15 Gold, 20 Gold, 25 Gold, 50 Gold, 75 Gold, Green Scale, Blue Ink, Lidless Demon Armor (Leggings), Neutral STarter Polo, Ocean Summer Top, 25 Tokens, Turkey Dinner.
From "My Gaia": Aquarium Big Gem, Aquarium Space Robot, Birthwood Floor Tile, Cherrywood Floor Tile, 10 Gold, 15 Gold, 20 Gold, 50 Gold, 75 Gold, Grade F Fish Bait, Green Scale, Honorable Brown Cushion, House Fly, Blue Ink, Yellow Ink, Lidless Demon Armor (Leggings), Neutral Starter Polo, Pancakes, Single Unit Table, Sunflower, 10 Tokens, 25 Tokens, 50 Tokens, Turkey Dinner, Yellow Guppy.
From "Shops": 10 Gold, 15 Gold, 5 Gold.
From "Forums": Aquarium Background (Fun Machine), Aquarium Earth, 10 Gold, 15 Gold, 5 Gold, House Fly, Sunflower.
From "World": Aquarium Background (Fun Machine), Aquarium Christmas Gift, Aquarium Goldfish, Crumpled Zerox Paper Goldenrod, Green Scale, House Fly, Black Ink, Blue Ink, Brown Ink, Green Ink, Red Ink, White Ink, Yellow Ink, Pancakes, Sunflower.
From "Games": 2 x Grade F Fish Bait, Aquarium Goldfish, Aquarium Space Robot, Crumpled Zerox Paper Goldenrod, House Fly, Black Ink, Green Ink, Red Ink, Sunflower, 10 Tokens, 25 Tokens, 50 Tokens, Yellow Guppy.
Let me know if you want more information.