Floaroma
I'm saying, do you appreciate a cheaper better done avatar, or a cluttered expensive avatar.
There's no discussion there. You're already qualifying the cheaper avatar as "better", so what are we supposed to say? "Wow, I totally love the cluttered expensive avatar more even though it's objectively worse by the rules of the original hypothetical?"
rolleyes
I read a few of the first pages and you seem to be trying to make this a fair argument by saying, "Well, you could like ugly expensive avatars because you're just impressed by their sheer cost." Still not a lot of discussion there.
In short, people are not talking about what you want them to talk about because your original topic is incredibly shallow. The entire topic seems set up for people to be like, "You know, expensive avatars have their place, but I also like cheap, but tastefully color-balanced avatars. WEALTH ISN'T EVERYTHING."