I guess that was sorta how it went down with my infatuation with the Thief doll mouth... I was obsessed with the stupid overpriced thing until I found the smirk in Dappy Dandy, an item that I'd previously not cared a bit about. It's not exactly the same, but it doesn't run into the masquerade nose and it gives your avatar a cheeky expression so it's good enough for me.
I actually really dislike both the Wendy eyes and the new Ciel eyes, and I sort of dislike them equally. XD;; They're some of the items that I'll never quite understand the demand for.