Again Ontaros carries the conversation with Sil, while watching, and this time physically responding to the creature. He mulls over the noises and the motion, thoughts roll about in his head but strikes out a few of them as he goes before coming to two conclusions, food, or water, either the creature was trying to make his hand flail about looking like a fish, or it was waving his hand, the sounds could fit both possible scenario.... He holds out both hands, his right hand transforms and becomes a fish hooked on a line, fliping and flopping about in the air, the line coming from the end of his sleeve which was still being supported by something rigid. His left hand he holds out, index finger pointed down with a slow steady stream of water pouring from it. He watches and waits for the creatures reactions. He assumed if these were inaccurate assumptions he'd simply reassess and try again.
As he performs for the creature he responds "Healthy animals are about as logical as they come my dear, if anything its people who seem to behave without reason. Animals run on instinct and a drive to survive. They're very simplistic in what they want and require little to survive. People on the other hand are overly complicated and neigh impossible to comprehend, truly it is we who have no place in nature. Greed, gluttony, lust, pride, wrath, sloth, envy. In nature, in the wild, these things have no meaning, no place, they don't exist. With humanoids, anything with a 'higher' intelligence for that matter, seems to strive for these unnecessary things, its almost as if it's what brings value to their lives. I myself am not exempt from that statement, but I try to keep these things in check. Animals are only greedy for survival, glut on scraping by to see tomorrow, lust for life, pride themselves in being, are wrathful to protect themselves, slothful to recover from the day or to survive a long cold winter, and envy no one. Simple creatures do simple things to live simple lives through simple, though uncertain days. Just watch, I'll prove to you someone is still in there." Though the wizard indeed spoke with conviction in his heart, there was no anger towards the woman in his words, in fact his words were tinted with guilt.