Mine is Maes Hughes. He was a pretty cool cat. I loved everything about his personality. I actually cried when he died. (I blame being preggers. sweatdrop) Especially during the funeral when Elicia was tugging Gracia's dress... crying
**EDIT: Homunculus do count. Just saying because of the minor confusion.
Love love LOVE Maes Hughes to bits. However, if you'd said "favourite character who can't do alchemy" instead of "couldn't" (implying the big spoil for the end, mayhap), I'd say Ed. xp