which full metal alchemist saga is better?

[thiSISed94R]

Dante_almont

hey guys i saw both FMA and FMA Shintetsu and i think they both were pretty awesome. Now i asked myself, which of them was better. In my opinion, Shintetsu was better because it was more based on the manga than the earlier one. But that's my opinion of course. Who do you guys think it was better?

FMA: Brotherhood is definitely the better one in my opinion because it was based on the manga.
i do however like the road they took in FMA, but my only problem was that they could have done so much more at the end.
i would have loved to see Edward and Hoenheim (or however it was spelled) go about their life in the WW I/II time period trying to get back to their time period w/o alchemy. it would have been quite the show.

[4elic]

I liked them both, I liked the animation and scenes in FMAB although I liked that in FMA each homunculi had its own story... If I had to choose, the second one for the characters and the ending.

[Squall_SeeD Mercenary]

The original hands down........the story kept you guessing what changes will come

[awin56]

i preferred the original over brotherhood, although i'm not finished with brotherhood the storyline of the original just seemed better... especially the way you killed the homonculi

[D0kt0r Bulletz]

B R O T H E R H O O D