I'd love to say that Ed would, but in the series Ed admits that he's never beaten Al in hand-to-hand which makes my decision a little harder. So I guess I'll go with it being a draw, especailly since I don't think they'd ever fight each other with the intent to kill which makes all the difference. xp
Riza restrains ed with a hail of bullets, while she freezes al with a death glare. Knowing that any harm brought upon the Brigadier general's fav Lieutenant is tantamout to suicide;ed is forced to take cover, wheras al is too meek to offer assistance to his brother, as it would encur the wrath of Hawkeye.